arXiv:2506.12301cs.LGcs.AI2025-06ACL被引 12

发现大模型推理中存在确认偏见,影响判断准确性。

Unveiling Confirmation Bias in Chain-of-Thought Reasoning

  • 将推理拆解为生成与预测两阶段,分析模型信念如何影响过程
  • 实验证明模型信念会扭曲推理路径并左右最终答案选择
  • 揭示不同任务效果差异根源,适合改进提示策略的研究者

链式思维(CoT)提示被广泛用于提升大语言模型(LLM)的推理能力,但其在不同推理类型任务中的表现不一致。本文从认知心理学中的确认偏见视角,分析模型内部信念(通过直接问答概率近似)如何影响链式思维中的推理生成(Q→R)和基于推理的答案预测(QR→A)。通过将CoT分解为两阶段,我们对模型信念、推理特征与分阶段性能进行了相关性分析。结果有力证明了LLMs中存在确认偏见:模型信念不仅扭曲推理过程,也影响推理被用于答案预测的方式。此外,任务对确认偏见的敏感性与信念强度之间的相互作用,解释了不同任务与模型下CoT效果的差异。本研究为设计更优提示策略以缓解确认偏见、提升推理性能提供了关键洞见。代码已公开于 https://github.com/yuewan2/biasedcot。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting has been widely adopted to enhance the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs). However, the effectiveness of CoT reasoning is inconsistent across tasks with different reasoning types. This work presents a novel perspective to understand CoT behavior through the lens of \textit{confirmation bias} in cognitive psychology. Specifically, we examine how model internal beliefs, approximated by direct question-answering probabilities, affect both reasoning generation ($Q \to R$) and reasoning-guided answer prediction ($QR \to A$) in CoT. By decomposing CoT into a two-stage process, we conduct a thorough correlation analysis in model beliefs, rationale attributes, and stage-wise performance. Our results provide strong evidence of confirmation bias in LLMs, such that model beliefs not only skew the reasoning process but also influence how rationales are utilized for answer prediction. Furthermore, the interplay between task vulnerability to confirmation bias and the strength of beliefs also provides explanations for CoT effectiveness across reasoning tasks and models. Overall, this study provides a valuable insight for the needs of better prompting strategies that mitigate confirmation bias to enhance reasoning performance. Code is available at \textit{https://github.com/yuewan2/biasedcot}.

链式思维认知偏见大模型推理

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。