用大模型模拟专家方法,评估新闻媒体的可信度与政治倾向。
Profiling News Media for Factuality and Bias Using LLMs and the Fact-Checking Methodology of Human Experts
- 基于专家事实核查标准设计提示词,让大模型评估媒体整体可靠性。
- 在多个媒体数据集上显著优于基线模型,尤其对冷门媒体更准确。
- 公开数据集与代码,适合研究信息生态与媒体偏见的学者使用。
在虚假和错误信息泛滥的网络时代,帮助读者理解所读内容至关重要。现有工作多依赖人工或自动事实核查,但面对新出现且信息有限的声明时,常难以应对。为此,我们转向评估信息来源的可靠性与政治偏见,即对整个新闻媒体进行画像,而非单篇报道。这是重要但研究不足的方向。不同于以往分析文章或社交媒体内容,本文提出一种新方法,模拟专业事实核查员对媒体整体的评估标准。具体而言,我们基于核查标准设计多种提示词,通过大语言模型(LLMs)生成响应,并聚合结果做出预测。在多个大型模型上进行广泛实验,结果显示该方法显著优于强基线。我们还深入分析了媒体知名度与地区对模型性能的影响,并通过消融实验揭示数据集关键成分的作用。为促进后续研究,我们已将数据集与代码开源至 https://github.com/mbzuai-nlp/llm-media-profiling。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
In an age characterized by the proliferation of mis- and disinformation online, it is critical to empower readers to understand the content they are reading. Important efforts in this direction rely on manual or automatic fact-checking, which can be challenging for emerging claims with limited information. Such scenarios can be handled by assessing the reliability and the political bias of the source of the claim, i.e., characterizing entire news outlets rather than individual claims or articles. This is an important but understudied research direction. While prior work has looked into linguistic and social contexts, we do not analyze individual articles or information in social media. Instead, we propose a novel methodology that emulates the criteria that professional fact-checkers use to assess the factuality and political bias of an entire outlet. Specifically, we design a variety of prompts based on these criteria and elicit responses from large language models (LLMs), which we aggregate to make predictions. In addition to demonstrating sizable improvements over strong baselines via extensive experiments with multiple LLMs, we provide an in-depth error analysis of the effect of media popularity and region on model performance. Further, we conduct an ablation study to highlight the key components of our dataset that contribute to these improvements. To facilitate future research, we released our dataset and code at https://github.com/mbzuai-nlp/llm-media-profiling.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。