测试大模型在教材问答中的表现,发现图文推理会引发严重性能下降。
Evaluating Multimodal Large Language Models on Educational Textbook Question Answering
- 用检索增强生成模拟真实学习场景,提供课文和图表作为上下文。
- 强模型在图文题上准确率从74.07%暴跌至25.93%,出现灾难性干扰。
- 适合关注AI教育工具鲁棒性与多模态融合的开发者和研究者。
多模态大语言模型在视觉-语言任务中表现优异,但在复杂教育材料上的推理能力仍缺乏评估。本文首次对前沿模型如LLaVA-1.5和LLaMA 3.2-Vision在教材问答(TQA)任务上的表现进行评测,使用CK12-QA数据集。我们引入多模态检索增强生成(RAG)流程,通过提供相关课文段落和图表作为上下文,模拟真实学习环境。零样本实验揭示关键权衡:检索上下文虽提升LLaVA在文本题上的表现,却使更强大的LLaMA 3.2-Vision在图表题上的验证准确率从74.07%大幅降至25.93%。我们称此显著现象为“灾难性上下文干扰”。此外,微调结果显示,LLaMA 3.2-Vision在测试集上性能提升至71.16%,展现出学习多模态整合的能力;而LLaVA性能反而下降,暴露出泛化难题。结果凸显多模态模型在模态优先级与上下文融合方面的挑战,为开发更稳健的AI教育工具提供了基准与方向。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have shown success in vision-language tasks, but their ability to reason over complex educational materials remains largely untested. This work presents the first evaluation of state-of-the-art MLLMs, including LLaVA-1.5 and LLaMA 3.2-Vision, on the textbook question answering (TQA) task using the CK12-QA dataset. We introduce a multimodal retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) pipeline to simulate real-world learning by providing relevant lesson paragraphs and diagrams as context. Our zero-shot experiments reveal a critical trade-off: while retrieved context improves LLaVA's performance on text-based questions, it significantly degrades the accuracy of the more powerful LLaMA 3.2-Vision on diagram-based tasks, dropping its validation accuracy from 74.07% to 25.93%. We term this statistically significant phenomenon "catastrophic context interference." Furthermore, fine-tuning highlights architectural differences: LLaMA 3.2-Vision's performance improves to 71.16% on the test set, demonstrating its capacity to learn multimodal integration, whereas LLaVA's performance declines, indicating challenges with generalization. Our results underscore the challenges MLLMs face in modality prioritization and context integration, providing a benchmark and pointing to key directions for developing more robust AI-driven educational tools.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。