arXiv:2507.00265cs.LGq-bio.NC2025-07

用模拟实验检验拒绝关系如何干扰等价类形成。

Examining Reject Relations in Stimulus Equivalence Simulations

  • 用神经网络模拟等价学习,测试不同训练结构与拒绝关系的影响
  • 多数模型在拒绝关系下表现优异,但与纯关联模型相当
  • 提醒需警惕混淆等价与关联学习,尤其在带拒绝条件时

模拟为探索刺激等价(SE)提供了有效工具,但拒绝关系是否干扰等价类形成仍存争议。本研究利用计算模型考察拒绝关系在等价学习中的作用,测试了前馈神经网络(FFNs)、BERT 和 GPT 在 18 种匹配到样本(MTS)模拟条件下的表现。条件包括训练结构(线性序列、一对一、多对一)、关系类型(仅选择、仅拒绝、选择-拒绝)以及负向比较选择方式(标准与偏差)。以概率代理作为纯关联学习基准。主要目标是判断人工神经网络能否表现出等价类形成,还是仅依赖关联策略。结果表明,拒绝关系影响代理性能;尽管部分模型在含拒绝关系及偏差负向比较条件下获得高准确率,但其表现与概率代理相当。这表明人工神经网络,包括变换器模型,可能依赖关联策略而非真正的等价学习。因此,需谨慎对待拒绝关系,并采用更严格的标准评估计算模型中的等价行为。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Simulations offer a valuable tool for exploring stimulus equivalence (SE), yet the potential of reject relations to disrupt the assessment of equivalence class formation is contentious. This study investigates the role of reject relations in the acquisition of stimulus equivalence using computational models. We examined feedforward neural networks (FFNs), bidirectional encoder representations from transformers (BERT), and generative pre-trained transformers (GPT) across 18 conditions in matching-to-sample (MTS) simulations. Conditions varied in training structure (linear series, one-to-many, and many-to-one), relation type (select-only, reject-only, and select-reject), and negative comparison selection (standard and biased). A probabilistic agent served as a benchmark, embodying purely associative learning. The primary goal was to determine whether artificial neural networks could demonstrate equivalence class formation or whether their performance reflected associative learning. Results showed that reject relations influenced agent performance. While some agents achieved high accuracy on equivalence tests, particularly with reject relations and biased negative comparisons, this performance was comparable to the probabilistic agent. These findings suggest that artificial neural networks, including transformer models, may rely on associative strategies rather than SE. This underscores the need for careful consideration of reject relations and more stringent criteria in computational models of equivalence.

等价学习神经网络模拟实验关联学习

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。