构建气候变迁视觉隐喻数据库,分析其传播效果与认知成本。
MetaClimage: A novel database of visual metaphors related to Climate Change, with costs and benefits analysis
- 建立包含隐喻与直白图像的视觉隐喻数据库,含人工评分。
- 隐喻图像理解更难但更美观,高思辨需求者情绪反应更强。
- 适合环境传播研究者、科普设计师及视觉叙事创作者使用。
气候变迁的视觉隐喻(如将融化的冰川描绘为融化的冰制手榴弹)被视为应对环境挑战复杂性的有效工具。然而,由于材料分散,相关研究较少。本文推出首个视觉隐喻气候变迁数据库MetaClimage(https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15861012),包含隐喻图像与对应直白图像,并附有人工评分:难度、有效性、艺术性与情绪唤醒度;同时收集参与者生成的标签以总结信息。通过自然语言处理从标签中提取语义与情感变量。结果显示,视觉隐喻图像理解难度更高,但艺术性更佳,有效性与情绪唤醒度无显著差异;但对高思辨需求者而言,情绪反应更强。隐喻图像获得更多标签,常提及图像未呈现的实体,且引发更具正向情感与更强主导性的词汇。这表明视觉隐喻虽增加认知负荷,却可能促进深层认知加工与抽象思维。尽管在普遍有效性上未优于直白图像,其美学价值与积极体验更为突出。本研究既提供研究数据库,也揭示了视觉隐喻在环境传播中的成本-收益权衡。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Visual metaphors of climate change (e.g., melting glaciers depicted as a melting ice grenade) are regarded as valuable tools for addressing the complexity of environmental challenges. However, few studies have examined their impact on communication, also due to scattered availability of material. Here, we present a novel database of Metaphors of Climate Change in Images (MetaClimage) https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15861012, paired with literal images and enriched with human ratings. For each image, we collected values of difficulty, efficacy, artistic quality, and emotional arousal from human rating, as well as number of tags generated by participants to summarize the message. Semantic and emotion variables were further derived from the tags via Natural Language Processing. Visual metaphors were rated as more difficult to understand, yet more aesthetically pleasant than literal images, but did not differ in efficacy and arousal. The latter for visual metaphors, however, was higher in participants with higher Need For Cognition. Furthermore, visual metaphors received more tags, often referring to entities not depicted in the image, and elicited words with more positive valence and greater dominance than literal images. These results evidence the greater cognitive load of visual metaphors, which nevertheless might induce positive effects such as deeper cognitive elaboration and abstraction compared to literal stimuli. Furthermore, while they are not deemed as more effective and arousing, visual metaphors seem to generate superior aesthetic appreciation and a more positively valenced experience. Overall, this study contributes to understanding the impact of visual metaphors of climate change both by offering a database for future research and by elucidating a cost-benefit trade-off to take into account when shaping environmental communication.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。