梳理智能体网络三十年演进,揭示语义从数据到模型的迁移规律。
From Multi-Agent Systems and the Semantic Web to Agentic AI: A Unified Narrative of the Web of Agents
- 按语义部署位置划分三代智能体系统:平台协调、数据标注、模型理解
- 指出当前智能体系统困局源于语义定位不当,关键挑战跨代持续存在
- 适合关注AI标准、协议设计与智能体生态的开发者与政策制定者
智能体网络(WoA)将文档为中心的网络转变为由自主代理代表用户行动的环境,这一愿景在大语言模型成熟后变得可行。我们提出,过去三十年中,WoA经历了语义努力的迁移:从平台侧协调(多智能体系统,第一代),到数据侧标注(语义网,第二代),再到模型侧理解(大模型时代,第三代)。这一代际跃迁——即“语义在数据”向“语义在模型”的转变——具有预测性:每一代的失败模式与现存问题均源于其语义定位所在。本文贡献五点:(i) 跨1990–2026年的统一演化叙事;(ii) 四维比较框架(语义基础、通信范式、智能归属、发现机制)统一应用于三代;(iii) 对十六个代表性系统的分类;(iv) 覆盖2024年11月–2026年8月的机构协同进展(如Linux基金会智能体联盟、A2A v1.0、MCP 2024年11月发布及2025年11月规范、Visa/Mastercard/Stripe支付协议、欧盟人工智能法案分阶段实施、NIST智能体标准计划、国际人工智能安全报告2026);(v) 七条基于跨代证据的教训,以及七个不随协议更迭而改变的恒久挑战。未来进展更依赖于标准组织、监管机构与商业支付网络正在构建的社会技术基础设施。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
The Web of Agents (WoA) transforms the document-centric Web into an environment of autonomous agents acting on users' behalf, a vision newly tractable as large language models (LLMs) mature. We argue that across three decades the WoA has undergone a \emph{semantic-effort migration} in chronological order: from platform-side coordination (Multi-Agent Systems, Generation~I), through data-side annotation (Semantic Web, Generation~II), to model-side interpretation (LLM-era, Generation~III). The central Gen~II~$\rightarrow$~Gen~III transition within this trajectory, which we call the \emph{semantics-in-data $\rightarrow$ semantics-in-models} shift, is predictive: each generation's failure modes and current open problems follow from where that generation located its semantic effort. The survey makes five contributions: (i)~a unified evolutionary narrative spanning 1990--2026; (ii)~a four-dimensional comparative framework (semantic foundation, communication paradigm, locus of intelligence, discovery mechanism) applied uniformly across all three generations; (iii)~classification of sixteen representative systems on these dimensions, including hybrid LLM--knowledge-graph and computer-use agents; (iv)~coverage of the November~2024--August~2026 institutional convergence (Linux Foundation's Agentic AI Foundation, A2A v1.0, MCP November~2024 launch and November~2025 specification, Visa/Mastercard/Stripe payment-network protocols, EU AI Act phased enforcement, the NIST AI Agent Standards Initiative, International AI Safety Report 2026); and (v)~seven named lessons grounded in cross-generational evidence paired with seven generation-invariant challenges that persist regardless of which protocol prevails. Further progress depends less on protocol design than on the socio-technical infrastructure now being assembled by standards bodies, regulators, and commercial payment networks.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。