arXiv:2507.11597cs.CYcs.AI2025-07

AI可辅助数据科学工作,但需警惕自动化带来的理解缺失风险。

AI, Humans, and Data Science: Optimizing Roles Across Workflows and the Workforce

  • 以真理、美、正义框架评估AI在数据分析中的角色
  • 强调人类与AI协作,避免盲目依赖智能工具
  • 适合关注研究伦理与人机协同的数据科学家

人工智能正重塑研究流程,被用于设计调查、整合数据、执行分析并撰写结果总结。尽管其旨在提升效率与质量,实际效果却不尽相同。本文基于真理、美、正义(TBJ)评估框架,审视分析型、生成型与自主型AI在辅助或替代数据科学家方面的潜力与局限。我们警示‘一键自动化’可能重演过去统计软件普及时出现的误解问题——即研究人员因缺乏理解而误用分析方法。文章倡导在整个数据科学工作流中坚持人机协作,尤其在充满不确定性、复杂性、模糊性和易变性的决策环境中,凸显数据科学家的关键作用。最后呼吁推进能够补足人类能力的AI工具,同时持续加强方法论培训,确保研究成果能被有效、伦理地应用与解读。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

AI is transforming research. It is being leveraged to construct surveys, synthesize data, conduct analysis, and write summaries of the results. While the promise is to create efficiencies and increase quality, the reality is not always as clear cut. Leveraging our framework of Truth, Beauty, and Justice (TBJ) which we use to evaluate AI, machine learning and computational models for effective and ethical use (Taber and Timpone 1997; Timpone and Yang 2024), we consider the potential and limitation of analytic, generative, and agentic AI to augment data scientists or take on tasks traditionally done by human analysts and researchers. While AI can be leveraged to assist analysts in their tasks, we raise some warnings about push-button automation. Just as earlier eras of survey analysis created some issues when the increased ease of using statistical software allowed researchers to conduct analyses they did not fully understand, the new AI tools may create similar but larger risks. We emphasize a human-machine collaboration perspective (Daugherty and Wilson 2018) throughout the data science workflow and particularly call out the vital role that data scientists play under VUCA decision areas. We conclude by encouraging the advance of AI tools to complement data scientists but advocate for continued training and understanding of methods to ensure the substantive value of research is fully achieved by applying, interpreting, and acting upon results most effectively and ethically.

人机协作数据科学AI伦理

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。