用大模型提升社会模拟,但需警惕其认知偏差与可复现性问题。
Integrating LLM in Agent-Based Social Simulation: Opportunities and Challenges
- 将大模型融入多智能体框架,结合经典建模平台提升表达力。
- 发现大模型在心理理论与社会推理上表现接近人类,但存在行为不一致。
- 适合交互式模拟与严肃游戏,解释性建模中需谨慎使用。
本文从计算社会科学视角探讨大语言模型(LLMs)在社会模拟中的应用潜力与局限。首先回顾近期研究发现,LLMs 能够部分复现人类认知的关键特征,如心智理论推理与社会推断,但仍存在认知偏见、缺乏具身理解及行为不一致性等固有问题。接着调研了新兴的多智能体仿真框架中 LLM 的应用,分析系统架构、可扩展性与验证策略。以 Generative Agents(Smallville)和 AgentSociety 为例,评估其经验基础与方法设计。重点关注大规模 LLM 驱动模拟中的行为保真度、校准与可复现性挑战。最后区分不同场景:在交互式模拟与严肃游戏等场景中,LLM 智能体具有实际价值;但在解释或预测建模中则引发认识论风险。建议将 LLM 与经典基于代理的模型(ABMs)结合,通过如 GAMA、NetLogo 等平台构建混合架构,提升透明性与灵活性。由此提出‘混合宪法架构’这一概念,即在统一平台内分层集成经典 ABMs、小语言模型(SLMs)与 LLMs。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
This position paper examines the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) in social simulation, analyzing their potential and limitations from a computational social science perspective. We first review recent findings on LLMs' ability to replicate key aspects of human cognition, including Theory of Mind reasoning and social inference, while identifying persistent limitations such as cognitive biases, lack of grounded understanding, and behavioral inconsistencies. We then survey emerging applications of LLMs in multi-agent simulation frameworks, examining system architectures, scalability, and validation strategies. Projects such as Generative Agents (Smallville) and AgentSociety are analyzed with respect to their empirical grounding and methodological design. Particular attention is given to the challenges of behavioral fidelity, calibration, and reproducibility in large-scale LLM-driven simulations. Finally, we distinguish between contexts where LLM-based agents provide operational value-such as interactive simulations and serious games-and contexts where their use raises epistemic concerns, particularly in explanatory or predictive modeling. We argue that hybrid approaches integrating LLMs into established agent-based modeling platforms such as GAMA and NetLogo may offer a promising compromise between expressive flexibility and analytical transparency. Building on this analysis, we outline a conceptual research direction termed Hybrid Constitutional Architectures, which proposes a stratified integration of classical agent-based models (ABMs), small language models (SLMs), and LLMs within established platforms such as GAMA and NetLogo.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。