arXiv:2508.03550cs.CL2025-08NeurIPS被引 10

利用大模型内部表示提升自动评分与人类判断的一致性。

Beyond the Surface: Enhancing LLM-as-a-Judge Alignment with Human via Internal Representations

  • 通过融合多层内部表示生成更精准的评分。
  • 在多个基准上提升7.5%相关性,优于现有方法。
  • 无需微调或推理步骤,适合直接部署于评估任务。

评估任务规模的扩大促使使用大语言模型进行自动化评估,即“大模型作为评判者”(LLM-as-a-Judge)。然而,不依赖复杂提示或微调来提升其与人类偏好的一致性仍具挑战。以往研究主要基于浅层输出,忽略了深层的跨层表示。本工作受初步发现启发:中上层编码了语义和任务相关的表示,往往比最终层更接近人类判断。为此提出 LAGER,一种后处理、即插即用的框架,通过整合跨层得分-标记逻辑值并基于Softmax分布计算期望得分,提升点对点评估与人类评分的一致性。该方法保持模型主干冻结,不影响推理过程。实验在Flask、HelpSteer、BIGGen标准基准上以斯皮尔曼相关系数评估,结果显示LAGER相较最佳基线最高提升7.5%。在无推理步骤条件下,性能匹配或超越基于推理的方法。下游任务如数据选择与情绪理解也验证了其泛化能力。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

The growing scale of evaluation tasks has led to the widespread adoption of automated evaluation using LLMs, a paradigm known as "LLM-as-a-judge". However, improving its alignment with human preferences without complex prompts or fine-tuning remains challenging. Previous studies mainly optimize based on shallow outputs, overlooking rich cross-layer representations. In this work, motivated by preliminary findings that middle-to-upper layers encode semantically and task-relevant representations that are often more aligned with human judgments than the final layer, we propose LAGER, a post-hoc, plug-and-play framework for improving the alignment of LLM-as-a-Judge point-wise evaluations with human scores by leveraging internal representations. LAGER produces fine-grained judgment scores by aggregating cross-layer score-token logits and computing the expected score from a softmax-based distribution, while keeping the LLM backbone frozen and ensuring no impact on the inference process. LAGER fully leverages the complementary information across different layers, overcoming the limitations of relying solely on the final layer. We evaluate our method on the standard alignment benchmarks Flask, HelpSteer, and BIGGen using Spearman correlation, and find that LAGER achieves improvements of up to 7.5% over the best baseline across these benchmarks. Without reasoning steps, LAGER matches or outperforms reasoning-based methods. Experiments on downstream applications, such as data selection and emotional understanding, further show the generalization of LAGER.

大模型评估表示对齐零样本优化

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。