arXiv:2508.10161cs.CLcs.AI2025-08被引 1

为评估大模型评分能力,提出可模拟测试的框架,解决低资源场景下指标失效问题。

LaajMeter: A Framework for LaaJ Evaluation

  • 构建仿真框架,生成虚拟模型与评分者进行可控测试
  • 发现常用指标对评分质量敏感度差异大,阈值需任务定制
  • 适合在数据稀缺的垂直领域验证评分系统可靠性

大语言模型作为评判者(LaaJ)在自然语言处理中日益普及,但其元评估面临挑战:特定领域标注数据少、专家评估成本高,导致常用指标未经验证即被应用。这使得难以判断哪些指标能有效识别评分质量,也难确定合格的性能阈值。本文提出LaajMeter——一个基于仿真的可控元评估框架,支持生成代表虚拟模型与裁判的合成数据,可在真实条件下系统分析评估指标表现。该框架帮助工程师验证特定任务中的评分器:检验指标是否能正确区分高质量与低质量的虚拟评判者,并估算达标阈值。我们在涉及老旧编程语言的代码翻译任务中验证了其有效性,结果显示不同指标对评判质量的敏感性各异。结果凸显常见指标的局限性,强调需有依据地选择评估方法。LaajMeter为低资源环境下的大模型评分评估提供可扩展、可延伸的解决方案,助力提升NLP评估的可信度与可复现性。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used as evaluators in natural language processing tasks, a paradigm known as LLM-as-a-Judge (LaaJ). The analysis of a LaaJ software, commonly refereed to as meta-evaluation, pose significant challenges in domain-specific contexts. In such domains, in contrast to general domains, annotated data is scarce and expert evaluation is costly. As a result, meta-evaluation is often performed using metrics that have not been validated for the specific domain in which they are applied. Therefore, it becomes difficult to determine which metrics effectively identify LaaJ quality, and further, what threshold indicates sufficient evaluator performance. In this work, we introduce LaaJMeter, a simulation-based framework for controlled meta-evaluation of LaaJs. LaaJMeter enables engineers to generate synthetic data representing virtual models and judges, allowing systematic analysis of evaluation metrics under realistic conditions. This helps practitioners validate LaaJs for specific tasks: they can test whether their metrics correctly distinguish between high and low quality (virtual) LaaJs, and estimate appropriate thresholds for evaluator adequacy. We demonstrate the utility of LaaJMeter in a code translation task involving a legacy programming language, showing how different metrics vary in sensitivity to evaluator quality. Our results highlight the limitations of common metrics and the importance of principled metric selection. LaaJMeter provides a scalable and extensible solution for assessing LaaJs in low-resource settings, contributing to the broader effort to ensure trustworthy and reproducible evaluation in NLP.

大模型评估元评估代码生成

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。