arXiv:2508.12461cs.CL2025-08被引 15

GPT-OSS开源模型实测发现:小模型反而更优,代码生成强但多语言弱。

Is GPT-OSS Good? A Comprehensive Evaluation of OpenAI's Latest Open Source Models

  • 对比六款开源大模型,测试120B与20B稀疏架构性能表现
  • 20B模型在代码与知识推理上优于120B,且能耗更低
  • 揭示稀疏架构扩容未必提升效果,适合高效部署场景

2025年8月,OpenAI发布GPT-OSS系列模型,其为自GPT-2以来首次开源权重的大规模语言模型,包含120B和20B参数的专家混合架构。本文在标准推理环境下,对两款模型与六款其他开源模型(14.7B至235B参数)进行评估,涵盖通用知识、数学推理、代码生成、多语言理解及对话能力共十项基准测试。所有模型以未量化形式运行,并采用麦克内马尔检验和效应量分析进行统计验证。结果表明,gpt-oss-20B在HumanEval与MMLU等基准上持续优于gpt-oss-120B,同时响应所需内存与能耗显著更低。两模型整体表现处于当前开源模型中段,代码生成能力突出,但多语言任务表现较弱。该结果表明,稀疏架构下模型规模扩大未必带来性能线性提升,凸显优化策略研究的重要性,为未来开源模型选型提供实证参考。更多细节与评估脚本详见项目主页:https://ai-agent-lab.github.io/gpt-oss。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

In August 2025, OpenAI released GPT-OSS models, its first open weight large language models since GPT-2 in 2019, comprising two mixture of experts architectures with 120B and 20B parameters. We evaluated both variants against six contemporary open source large language models ranging from 14.7B to 235B parameters, representing both dense and sparse designs, across ten benchmarks covering general knowledge, mathematical reasoning, code generation, multilingual understanding, and conversational ability. All models were tested in unquantised form under standardised inference settings, with statistical validation using McNemars test and effect size analysis. Results show that gpt-oss-20B consistently outperforms gpt-oss-120B on several benchmarks, such as HumanEval and MMLU, despite requiring substantially less memory and energy per response. Both models demonstrate mid-tier overall performance within the current open source landscape, with relative strength in code generation and notable weaknesses in multilingual tasks. These findings provide empirical evidence that scaling in sparse architectures may not yield proportional performance gains, underscoring the need for further investigation into optimisation strategies and informing more efficient model selection for future open source deployments. More details and evaluation scripts are available at https://ai-agent-lab.github.io/gpt-oss (Project Webpage).

大模型评测开源模型代码生成稀疏架构

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。