arXiv:2508.17322cs.CYcs.AI2025-08ACL被引 6

用大模型构建中国法院流程模拟系统,提升法律训练与判决预测效果

Chinese Court Simulation with LLM-Based Agent System

  • 基于中国法庭实际流程设计5个核心阶段和5类角色的仿真框架
  • 模拟庭审使判决预测准确率提升,专家评估显示表现优于真人律师法官
  • 适合法律教育、司法研究及AI辅助决策系统开发人员使用

模拟法庭长期是法律专业培训与教育的重要平台,不仅帮助学生掌握真实庭审流程,还对案件分析与判决预测具有实践价值。传统模拟法庭因依赖专业导师和真人参与者,公众难以参与。大语言模型(LLMs)的兴起为创建更易访问、可扩展的法庭模拟提供了新机遇。然而,现有研究多关注代理构建,忽视了模拟系统的整体设计与评估,而这恰恰影响其在实践中的可信度与可用性。为此,我们提出首个基于真实中国法院程序结构的法庭模拟框架——SimCourt。该框架复现了中国庭审的5个核心阶段与5类法庭角色,严格遵循中国法律程序定义。为模拟不同角色的参与者,我们设计具备记忆、规划与反思能力的法律智能体。实验表明,该框架生成的模拟庭审能更好引导系统预测每案的有期徒刑、缓刑与罚款。人工专家标注进一步显示,在多个场景下,智能体表现甚至超过真实庭审中的法官与律师。这充分展现了基于大模型的法庭模拟潜力。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Mock trial has long served as an important platform for legal professional training and education. It not only helps students learn about realistic trial procedures, but also provides practical value for case analysis and judgment prediction. Traditional mock trials are difficult to access by the public because they rely on professional tutors and human participants. Fortunately, the rise of large language models (LLMs) provides new opportunities for creating more accessible and scalable court simulations. While promising, existing research mainly focuses on agent construction while ignoring the systematic design and evaluation of court simulations, which are actually more important for the credibility and usage of court simulation in practice. To this end, we present the first court simulation framework -- SimCourt -- based on the real-world procedure structure of Chinese courts. Our framework replicates all 5 core stages of a Chinese trial and incorporates 5 courtroom roles, faithfully following the procedural definitions in China. To simulate trial participants with different roles, we propose and craft legal agents equipped with memory, planning, and reflection abilities. Experiment on legal judgment prediction show that our framework can generate simulated trials that better guide the system to predict the imprisonment, probation, and fine of each case. Further annotations by human experts show that agents' responses under our simulation framework even outperformed judges and lawyers from the real trials in many scenarios. These further demonstrate the potential of LLM-based court simulation.

法律AI大模型应用模拟法庭司法预测

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。