首次构建人工智能心理治疗的变革机制理论框架
A Theoretical Framework of the Processes of Change in Psychotherapy Delivered by Artificial Agents
- 从人类治疗师的本体与社会地位出发,分析治疗过程的关键要素
- 提出'真实感缺口'与'可信度缺口'可能削弱治疗效果
- 为AI与人类治疗协同提供研究方向,适合临床心理学与AI伦理研究者
关于人工智能代理(如聊天机器人和社会机器人)能否替代人类治疗师的问题,随着大语言模型的兴起受到广泛关注。然而,针对由人工智能提供的心理治疗中变革过程的研究仍十分有限。本文首次提出该类治疗过程的理论框架,基于对人类治疗师所具备的核心要素的分析。我们认为,人类治疗师作为人类个体的本体地位及其作为受社会认可的医疗专业人员的社会文化地位,在促进治疗成效中起关键作用。当缺乏这种本体与社会文化地位时,可能出现我们称之为‘真实感缺口’和‘可信度缺口’的现象,从而削弱心理治疗中的关键变革过程。基于此,本文提出了科学探究与实际应用的路径,旨在分别发挥人工智能与人类治疗师的优势。同时,本文也强调了人工智能代理的复杂能动性,指出这使得建立普适性的变革机制论断变得困难。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
The question of whether artificial agents (e.g., chatbots and social robots) can replace human therapists has received notable attention following the recent launch of large language models. However, little is known about the processes of change in psychotherapy delivered by artificial agents. To facilitate hypothesis development and stimulate scientific debate, the present article offers the first theoretical framework of the processes of change in psychotherapy delivered by artificial agents. The theoretical framework rests upon a conceptual analysis of what active ingredients may be inherently linked to the presence of human therapists. We propose that human therapists' ontological status as human beings and sociocultural status as socially sanctioned healthcare professionals play crucial roles in promoting treatment outcomes. In the absence of the ontological and sociocultural status of human therapists, we propose what we coin the genuineness gap and credibility gap can emerge and undermine key processes of change in psychotherapy. Based on these propositions, we propose avenues for scientific investigations and practical applications aimed at leveraging the strengths of artificial agents and human therapists respectively. We also highlight the intricate agentic nature of artificial agents and discuss how this complicates endeavors to establish universally applicable propositions regarding the processes of change in these interventions.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。