arXiv:2509.03793cs.MAcs.AI2025-09被引 4

用AI模拟印度司法辩论,让法律推理可追踪可验证。

SAMVAD: A Multi-Agent System for Simulating Judicial Deliberation Dynamics in India

  • 构建多智能体系统,角色由LLM驱动并接入法律知识库
  • 通过检索增强生成实现论点带出处,提升论证透明度
  • 适合研究司法决策、法律教育或政策模拟的学者与机构

理解司法审议的复杂性对评估司法系统的效率与公平至关重要。然而,实证研究司法合议庭面临重大伦理和实践障碍。本文提出SAMVAD,一种创新的多智能体系统(MAS),用于模拟印度司法体系内的审议过程。系统包含代表法官、检方律师、辩方律师及多位裁判员(模拟合议庭)的智能体,均由大语言模型驱动。核心贡献在于整合了基于领域知识库(含印度刑法典、宪法等重要法律文件)的检索增强生成(RAG)技术,使法官与律师智能体能生成带来源引用的合法论据,提升模拟的真实性与可解释性。裁判员智能体通过多轮迭代审议,结合案件事实、法律指令与论点,达成共识性判决。本文详述系统架构、智能体通信协议、RAG流程、仿真工作流及综合评估方案,旨在衡量性能、审议质量与结果一致性。该研究提供了一个可配置、可解释的平台,适用于探索法律推理与群体决策在印度法律语境下的动态机制,并通过RAG实现可验证的法律依据支撑。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Understanding the complexities of judicial deliberation is crucial for assessing the efficacy and fairness of a justice system. However, empirical studies of judicial panels are constrained by significant ethical and practical barriers. This paper introduces SAMVAD, an innovative Multi-Agent System (MAS) designed to simulate the deliberation process within the framework of the Indian justice system. Our system comprises agents representing key judicial roles: a Judge, a Prosecution Counsel, a Defense Counsel, and multiple Adjudicators (simulating a judicial bench), all powered by large language models (LLMs). A primary contribution of this work is the integration of Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), grounded in a domain-specific knowledge base of landmark Indian legal documents, including the Indian Penal Code and the Constitution of India. This RAG functionality enables the Judge and Counsel agents to generate legally sound instructions and arguments, complete with source citations, thereby enhancing both the fidelity and transparency of the simulation. The Adjudicator agents engage in iterative deliberation rounds, processing case facts, legal instructions, and arguments to reach a consensus-based verdict. We detail the system architecture, agent communication protocols, the RAG pipeline, the simulation workflow, and a comprehensive evaluation plan designed to assess performance, deliberation quality, and outcome consistency. This work provides a configurable and explainable MAS platform for exploring legal reasoning and group decision-making dynamics in judicial simulations, specifically tailored to the Indian legal context and augmented with verifiable legal grounding via RAG.

司法模拟多智能体RAG法律AI

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。