arXiv:2509.12577cs.CYcs.CL2025-09被引 1

用AI分析集体讨论中想法的演化与决策过程。

An AI-Powered Framework for Analyzing Collective Idea Evolution in Deliberative Assemblies

  • 基于大模型分析会议记录,追踪想法演变路径。
  • 还原每位代表观点变化,揭示投票影响机制。
  • 为民主议事会研究提供高精度动态分析工具。

在社会分裂、政治极化和公众信任下降的背景下,代表性的审议型会议正成为应对复杂全球议题的有效政策平台。尽管理论关注度高,但缺乏系统性实证研究来追踪具体想法如何在讨论中演进、优先或被舍弃,最终形成政策建议。本文提出两个核心问题:(1)如何追踪审议会议中思想演化并凝练为具体建议?(2)审议过程如何塑造代表观点并影响投票行为?为此,我们开发了基于大语言模型的方法,对一次技术增强的线下审议会议的发言记录进行实证分析。该框架可识别并可视化所提建议的语义空间,并重构每位代表在会议期间观点的动态演变。研究为审议过程提供了新颖的实证洞见,证明大模型能揭示传统输出中难以察觉的高分辨率动态过程。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

In an era of increasing societal fragmentation, political polarization, and erosion of public trust in institutions, representative deliberative assemblies are emerging as a promising democratic forum for developing effective policy outcomes on complex global issues. Despite theoretical attention, there remains limited empirical work that systematically traces how specific ideas evolve, are prioritized, or are discarded during deliberation to form policy recommendations. Addressing these gaps, this work poses two central questions: (1) How might we trace the evolution and distillation of ideas into concrete recommendations within deliberative assemblies? (2) How does the deliberative process shape delegate perspectives and influence voting dynamics over the course of the assembly? To address these questions, we develop LLM-based methodologies for empirically analyzing transcripts from a tech-enhanced in-person deliberative assembly. The framework identifies and visualizes the space of expressed suggestions. We also empirically reconstruct each delegate's evolving perspective throughout the assembly. Our methods contribute novel empirical insights into deliberative processes and demonstrate how LLMs can surface high-resolution dynamics otherwise invisible in traditional assembly outputs.

AI分析审议会议大模型应用

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。