arXiv:2509.15848cs.AI2025-09被引 15

对比工业监控中规则与数据驱动方法的优劣,提出融合方案。

A Comparative Study of Rule-Based and Data-Driven Approaches in Industrial Monitoring

  • 比较规则系统与数据驱动模型在工业监控中的表现
  • 规则方法可解释性强但难适应复杂环境,数据方法精准但依赖数据
  • 适合关注工业智能化与系统可信性的研究人员

工业监控系统在工业4.0背景下正从传统规则架构转向基于机器学习和人工智能的数据驱动方法。本文对比分析了两类方法的优势、局限及适用场景,并提出一个评估其核心特性的基础框架。规则系统具有高可解释性、确定性行为和易于实现的特点,适用于受监管行业和安全关键应用;但在复杂或动态环境中面临可扩展性、自适应能力差等问题。数据驱动系统在检测隐性异常、实现预测性维护和动态适应新条件方面表现优异,但受限于数据可用性、可解释性差和集成复杂度。研究建议采用混合解决方案,融合规则逻辑的透明性与机器学习的分析能力。论文认为,未来工业监控的发展方向是智能协同系统,结合专家知识与数据洞察,提升系统韧性、运行效率与信任度,推动更智能、灵活的工业环境发展。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Industrial monitoring systems, especially when deployed in Industry 4.0 environments, are experiencing a shift in paradigm from traditional rule-based architectures to data-driven approaches leveraging machine learning and artificial intelligence. This study presents a comparison between these two methodologies, analyzing their respective strengths, limitations, and application scenarios, and proposes a basic framework to evaluate their key properties. Rule-based systems offer high interpretability, deterministic behavior, and ease of implementation in stable environments, making them ideal for regulated industries and safety-critical applications. However, they face challenges with scalability, adaptability, and performance in complex or evolving contexts. Conversely, data-driven systems excel in detecting hidden anomalies, enabling predictive maintenance and dynamic adaptation to new conditions. Despite their high accuracy, these models face challenges related to data availability, explainability, and integration complexity. The paper suggests hybrid solutions as a possible promising direction, combining the transparency of rule-based logic with the analytical power of machine learning. Our hypothesis is that the future of industrial monitoring lies in intelligent, synergic systems that leverage both expert knowledge and data-driven insights. This dual approach enhances resilience, operational efficiency, and trust, paving the way for smarter and more flexible industrial environments.

工业监控规则系统数据驱动混合模型

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。