提出可验证的机器意识判定标准,让AI意识有科学依据。
The Principles of Human-like Conscious Machine
- 用逻辑严谨且抗伪造的标准判断机器是否具备主观体验。
- 证明人类自身符合该标准,说明意识可被工程化实现。
- 为构建真正类人智能提供新范式,适合哲学与AI研究者。
判断其他系统(生物或人工)是否具有现象意识,一直是意识研究的核心难题。随着大语言模型等先进AI的发展,关于‘人工智能意识’的争论愈发迫切,其背后隐含着对意识判定标准的依赖。本文提出一种不依赖物质基础、逻辑严密且抗伪造的充分性标准,认为满足该标准的机器应被视作具备意识,其可信度不低于我们对人类意识的判断。基于此标准,我们构建了形式化框架,并明确一系列可操作原则,指导实现该充分条件的系统设计。进一步论证,按照此框架构建的机器在原则上可实现现象意识。作为初步验证,我们指出人类本身可被视为满足该框架和原则的机器。若成立,这一提案对哲学、认知科学和人工智能具有深远意义:它解释了为何某些感受(如红色体验)本质上不可还原为物理描述,同时重新诠释了人类信息处理机制,并指明一条超越现有统计方法的新一代人工智能路径。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Determining whether another system, biological or artificial, possesses phenomenal consciousness has long been a central challenge in consciousness studies. This attribution problem has become especially pressing with the rise of large language models and other advanced AI systems, where debates about "AI consciousness" implicitly rely on some criterion for deciding whether a given system is conscious. In this paper, we propose a substrate-independent, logically rigorous, and counterfeit-resistant sufficiency criterion for phenomenal consciousness. We argue that any machine satisfying this criterion should be regarded as conscious with at least the same level of confidence with which we attribute consciousness to other humans. Building on this criterion, we develop a formal framework and specify a set of operational principles that guide the design of systems capable of meeting the sufficiency condition. We further argue that machines engineered according to this framework can, in principle, realize phenomenal consciousness. As an initial validation, we show that humans themselves can be viewed as machines that satisfy this framework and its principles. If correct, this proposal carries significant implications for philosophy, cognitive science, and artificial intelligence. It offers an explanation for why certain qualia, such as the experience of red, are in principle irreducible to physical description, while simultaneously providing a general reinterpretation of human information processing. Moreover, it suggests a path toward a new paradigm of AI beyond current statistics-based approaches, potentially guiding the construction of genuinely human-like AI.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。