用变分决策模型解释信念改变的成本如何导致认知偏差
On the Variational Costs of Changing Our Minds
- 将信念更新视为权衡信念效用与信息成本的变分决策
- 模型能定性复现确认偏误和态度极化等常见行为
- 适合研究认知偏差或人机交互中信念修正的学者
人类心智虽具非凡成就,却常自我对抗:固守既有信念、选择性解读信息以符合预期叙事、主动回避或寻找信息以满足目的。尽管这些行为偏离规范性的信念更新标准,我们主张此类‘偏差’并非认知缺陷,而是对信念修正所带来显著实用与认知成本的适应性反应。本文提出一个形式化框架,旨在建模这些成本对信念更新机制的影响。我们将信念更新视为一种受动机驱动的变分决策过程,其中个体权衡信念的感知效用与采用新信念状态所需的信息成本,该成本通过先验到变分后验之间的Kullback-Leibler散度量化。通过计算实验表明,该资源理性模型的简单实例可定性模拟常见的认知现象,如确认偏误与态度极化。本研究推动了对动机性贝叶斯信念变化机制的更全面理解,并为预测、补偿及纠正非理想信念更新提供了实际洞见。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
The human mind is capable of extraordinary achievements, yet it often appears to work against itself. It actively defends its cherished beliefs even in the face of contradictory evidence, conveniently interprets information to conform to desired narratives, and selectively searches for or avoids information to suit its various purposes. Despite these behaviours deviating from common normative standards for belief updating, we argue that such 'biases' are not inherently cognitive flaws, but rather an adaptive response to the significant pragmatic and cognitive costs associated with revising one's beliefs. This paper introduces a formal framework that aims to model the influence of these costs on our belief updating mechanisms. We treat belief updating as a motivated variational decision, where agents weigh the perceived 'utility' of a belief against the informational cost required to adopt a new belief state, quantified by the Kullback-Leibler divergence from the prior to the variational posterior. We perform computational experiments to demonstrate that simple instantiations of this resource-rational model can be used to qualitatively emulate commonplace human behaviours, including confirmation bias and attitude polarisation. In doing so, we suggest that this framework makes steps toward a more holistic account of the motivated Bayesian mechanics of belief change and provides practical insights for predicting, compensating for, and correcting deviations from desired belief updating processes.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。