arXiv:2509.21943cs.AIcs.LG2025-09

比较统计方法与可解释机器学习,提升足底压力数据异常检测准确性

Outlier Detection in Plantar Pressure: Human-Centered Comparison of Statistical Parametric Mapping and Explainable Machine Learning

  • 用卷积神经网络结合SHAP解释,自动识别足底压力异常
  • 模型准确率高,比传统统计方法更少误判临床变异、更易发现真实异常
  • 专家认为两种方法都清晰可信,适合医疗与运动科学中的数据质量控制

足底压力映射在临床诊断与运动科学中至关重要,但多中心异构数据常含因技术误差或流程不一致导致的异常值。本研究对比了统计参数映射(SPM)与可解释机器学习(ML)方法,构建透明的数据质控流程。数据来自多个中心,经专家共识标注,并加入合成异常,共得798个有效样本与2000个异常样本。评估包括:(i) 依赖配准的非参数化SPM方法,(ii) 使用SHAP解释的卷积神经网络(CNN)。通过嵌套交叉验证评估性能,利用领域专家的语义差异调查评估解释质量。结果表明,机器学习模型精度更高,优于SPM——后者误判了临床有意义的变异并遗漏真实异常。专家认为两者解释均清晰、有用且可信,尽管SPM被认为更简单。研究凸显了SPM与可解释机器学习在足底压力数据自动异常检测中的互补潜力,并强调可解释性对将复杂模型输出转化为可决策洞察的重要性。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Plantar pressure mapping is essential in clinical diagnostics and sports science, yet large heterogeneous datasets often contain outliers from technical errors or procedural inconsistencies. Statistical Parametric Mapping (SPM) provides interpretable analyses but is sensitive to alignment and its capacity for robust outlier detection remains unclear. This study compares an SPM approach with an explainable machine learning (ML) approach to establish transparent quality-control pipelines for plantar pressure datasets. Data from multiple centers were annotated by expert consensus and enriched with synthetic anomalies resulting in 798 valid samples and 2000 outliers. We evaluated (i) a non-parametric, registration-dependent SPM approach and (ii) a convolutional neural network (CNN), explained using SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP). Performance was assessed via nested cross-validation; explanation quality via a semantic differential survey with domain experts. The ML model reached high accuracy and outperformed SPM, which misclassified clinically meaningful variations and missed true outliers. Experts perceived both SPM and SHAP explanations as clear, useful, and trustworthy, though SPM was assessed less complex. These findings highlight the complementary potential of SPM and explainable ML as approaches for automated outlier detection in plantar pressure data, and underscore the importance of explainability in translating complex model outputs into interpretable insights that can effectively inform decision-making.

异常检测可解释AI足底压力医疗数据

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。