arXiv:2509.21972cs.CYcs.AI2025-09被引 22

系统梳理70项研究,揭示大模型在教育中的认知风险与应对策略。

From Superficial Outputs to Superficial Learning: Risks of Large Language Models in Education

  • 基于70项实证研究,归纳大模型教育应用的三大领域。
  • 发现模型存在幻觉、偏见等技术风险,引发学习依赖与能力退化。
  • 提出风险传导模型,适合教育科技研发者与政策制定者参考。

大型语言模型(LLMs)正在重塑教育,推动个性化学习、即时反馈与知识获取,但也带来学生与学习系统层面的风险。然而,相关实证证据仍分散零星。本文系统综述了计算机科学、教育学与心理学领域的70项实证研究,围绕四个核心问题展开:(i) LLM在教育中最常被研究的应用;(ii) 研究如何衡量其影响;(iii) 由此产生的风险;(iv) 提出的缓解策略。研究发现,相关研究集中于三大领域:运行有效性、个性化应用与交互式学习工具。模型层面的风险包括浅层理解、偏见、鲁棒性不足、拟人化倾向、幻觉、隐私问题与知识局限。当学习者与模型互动时,这些风险延伸至认知与行为后果,如神经活动降低、过度依赖、独立学习能力下降及主体性丧失。为此,我们提出一个‘大模型风险适配学习模型’,揭示技术风险如何通过交互与解释逐步演变为教育结果。作为首个整合实证评估风险的综述,本研究为负责任、以人为本的大模型教育融合奠定基础。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Large Language Models (LLMs) are transforming education by enabling personalization, feedback, and knowledge access, while also raising concerns about risks to students and learning systems. Yet empirical evidence on these risks remains fragmented. This paper presents a systematic review of 70 empirical studies across computer science, education, and psychology. Guided by four research questions, we examine: (i) which applications of LLMs in education have been most frequently explored; (ii) how researchers have measured their impact; (iii) which risks stem from such applications; and (iv) what mitigation strategies have been proposed. We find that research on LLMs clusters around three domains: operational effectiveness, personalized applications, and interactive learning tools. Across these, model-level risks include superficial understanding, bias, limited robustness, anthropomorphism, hallucinations, privacy concerns, and knowledge constraints. When learners interact with LLMs, these risks extend to cognitive and behavioural outcomes, including reduced neural activity, over-reliance, diminished independent learning skills, and a loss of student agency. To capture this progression, we propose an LLM-Risk Adapted Learning Model that illustrates how technical risks cascade through interaction and interpretation to shape educational outcomes. As the first synthesis of empirically assessed risks, this review provides a foundation for responsible, human-centred integration of LLMs in education.

大模型风险教育科技认知影响实证综述

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。