首个从因果视角评估医学影像预后公平性的框架,揭示了模型偏见的深层来源。
The Boundaries of Fair AI in Medical Image Prognosis: A Causal Perspective
- 引入因果分析技术,系统识别影像数据中的偏见来源。
- 发现不同模态下偏见普遍存在,现有公平方法效果有限。
- 适用于医疗AI研发者与政策制定者,关注长期预后公平性问题。
随着机器学习算法在医学影像分析中日益普及,其对特定社会群体的潜在偏见引发关注。尽管已有诸多公平性保障方法,但多数研究仅聚焦于图像分类、分割等诊断任务,忽略了涉及疾病进展预测的时间至事件(TTE)预后场景。为此,本文提出FairTTE——首个针对医学影像预后中时间至事件预测的全面公平性评估框架。该框架涵盖多种影像模态与TTE结果,整合前沿的TTE预测与公平性算法,支持对公平性的系统性、细粒度分析。通过因果分析技术,FairTTE揭示并量化了医学影像数据中嵌入的多种偏见来源。大规模评估表明,偏见在不同影像模态中普遍存在,且当前公平方法难以有效缓解。我们进一步证实,偏见来源与模型差异存在强关联,凸显需采取全面策略应对各类偏见。值得注意的是,当分布发生漂移时,公平性愈发难以维持,暴露出现有解决方案的局限性,亟需更稳健、更公平的预后模型。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
As machine learning (ML) algorithms are increasingly used in medical image analysis, concerns have emerged about their potential biases against certain social groups. Although many approaches have been proposed to ensure the fairness of ML models, most existing works focus only on medical image diagnosis tasks, such as image classification and segmentation, and overlooked prognosis scenarios, which involve predicting the likely outcome or progression of a medical condition over time. To address this gap, we introduce FairTTE, the first comprehensive framework for assessing fairness in time-to-event (TTE) prediction in medical imaging. FairTTE encompasses a diverse range of imaging modalities and TTE outcomes, integrating cutting-edge TTE prediction and fairness algorithms to enable systematic and fine-grained analysis of fairness in medical image prognosis. Leveraging causal analysis techniques, FairTTE uncovers and quantifies distinct sources of bias embedded within medical imaging datasets. Our large-scale evaluation reveals that bias is pervasive across different imaging modalities and that current fairness methods offer limited mitigation. We further demonstrate a strong association between underlying bias sources and model disparities, emphasizing the need for holistic approaches that target all forms of bias. Notably, we find that fairness becomes increasingly difficult to maintain under distribution shifts, underscoring the limitations of existing solutions and the pressing need for more robust, equitable prognostic models.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。