用论证模型提升法律AI透明度,符合欧盟法规要求
Argumentation-Based Explainability for Legal AI: Comparative and Regulatory Perspectives
- 采用计算论证框架解释法律AI决策过程
- 论证方法更契合法律的可辩驳性和价值敏感性
- 适合关注合规与可解释性的法律科技研究者
人工智能系统在法律领域的应用日益广泛,但其黑箱特性对公平性、问责制和信任构成挑战。为应对这一问题,可解释人工智能(XAI)提出多种方法,包括基于示例、规则及混合和论证式方法。本文倡导使用计算论证模型提供法律相关解释,特别关注其与欧盟《通用数据保护条例》(GDPR)和《人工智能法案》(AIA)等新兴监管框架的契合性。我们分析了不同解释策略的优劣,评估其在法律推理中的适用性,并强调论证框架能有效捕捉法律的可辩驳性、可争议性和价值敏感性,因而为可解释法律AI提供稳健基础。最后,我们指出开放挑战与研究方向,包括偏见缓解、司法场景下的实证验证,以及符合不断演进的伦理与法律标准,认为计算论证最有可能同时满足技术与规范层面的透明性要求。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems are increasingly deployed in legal contexts, where their opacity raises significant challenges for fairness, accountability, and trust. The so-called ``black box problem'' undermines the legitimacy of automated decision-making, as affected individuals often lack access to meaningful explanations. In response, the field of Explainable AI (XAI) has proposed a variety of methods to enhance transparency, ranging from example-based and rule-based techniques to hybrid and argumentation-based approaches. This paper promotes computational models of arguments and their role in providing legally relevant explanations, with particular attention to their alignment with emerging regulatory frameworks such as the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the Artificial Intelligence Act (AIA). We analyze the strengths and limitations of different explanation strategies, evaluate their applicability to legal reasoning, and highlight how argumentation frameworks -- by capturing the defeasible, contestable, and value-sensitive nature of law -- offer a particularly robust foundation for explainable legal AI. Finally, we identify open challenges and research directions, including bias mitigation, empirical validation in judicial settings, and compliance with evolving ethical and legal standards, arguing that computational argumentation is best positioned to meet both technical and normative requirements of transparency in the law domain.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。