用规则代替数据,让机器更懂古兰经诵读的正确发音。
A Critical Review of the Need for Knowledge-Centric Evaluation of Quranic Recitation
- 基于古兰经文本不变性,构建规则驱动的发音评估模型。
- 现有系统依赖有偏数据,难以提供有效改进建议。
- 适合语言教育、语音处理及宗教技术研究者参考。
古兰经诵读(Tajweed)是一门遵循严格语音、节奏与神学原则的学科,在数字时代面临严峻的教育挑战。尽管现代技术为学习提供了新可能,但现有的自动化评估系统尚未获得广泛认可或展现教学有效性。本文综述过去二十年间相关学术研究、数字平台与商业工具,揭示当前方法的根本缺陷:过度依赖以词识别为核心的自动语音识别(ASR)系统,忽视了声学质量的定性评估。这些系统受限于有偏数据集、人口统计差异,且无法提供有意义的学习反馈。为此,我们主张转向知识中心的计算框架,利用古兰经文本的恒定性与塔吉维德规则的明确性,建立以标准发音原则和发音点(Makhraj)为核心的规则化声学模型。结论指出,未来的评估系统应融合语言学专业知识与先进音频处理技术,发展出可靠、公平且具有教学价值的工具,真正助力全球学习者。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
The art and science of Quranic recitation (Tajweed), a discipline governed by meticulous phonetic, rhythmic, and theological principles, confronts substantial educational challenges in today's digital age. Although modern technology offers unparalleled opportunities for learning, existing automated systems for evaluating recitation have struggled to gain broad acceptance or demonstrate educational effectiveness. This literature review examines this crucial disparity, offering a thorough analysis of scholarly research, digital platforms, and commercial tools developed over the past twenty years. Our analysis uncovers a fundamental flaw in current approaches that adapt Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems, which emphasize word identification over qualitative acoustic evaluation. These systems suffer from limitations such as reliance on biased datasets, demographic disparities, and an inability to deliver meaningful feedback for improvement. Challenging these data-centric methodologies, we advocate for a paradigm shift toward a knowledge-based computational framework. By leveraging the unchanging nature of the Quranic text and the well-defined rules of Tajweed, we propose that an effective evaluation system should be built upon rule-based acoustic modeling centered on canonical pronunciation principles and articulation points (Makhraj), rather than depending on statistical patterns derived from flawed or biased data. The review concludes that the future of automated Quranic recitation assessment lies in hybrid systems that combine linguistic expertise with advanced audio processing. Such an approach paves the way for developing reliable, fair, and pedagogically effective tools that can authentically assist learners across the globe.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。