构建中文侵权案推理链条,提升大模型法律分析能力
LexChain: Modeling Legal Reasoning Chains for Chinese Tort Case Analysis
- 提出三模块可拆解的LexChain推理框架,细化侵权案分析流程
- 构建评估基准,发现现有大模型在关键环节仍表现不足
- 基于LexChain设计提示与微调基线,显著提升推理准确率
法律推理是法律分析与决策的核心。现有计算方法多依赖通用推理框架(如三段论),未能充分刻画法律推理的细微过程;且研究集中于刑事案件,对民事案件建模不足。本文提出LexChain框架,将中国侵权类民事案件的法律推理过程显式分解为三个模块,每个模块包含多个细粒度子步骤。基于此框架,我们定义侵权法律推理任务并构建评估基准,系统评估大模型在侵权分析推理链中各关键步骤的表现。实验表明,当前大模型在处理侵权推理核心要素方面仍有明显不足。为此,我们设计了基于LexChain提示或后训练的若干基线方法,显著提升大模型在侵权推理任务中的表现,并在相关法律分析任务上具有良好泛化性,验证了显式建模推理链对增强语言模型推理能力的价值。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Legal reasoning is a fundamental component of legal analysis and decision-making. Existing computational approaches to legal reasoning predominantly rely on generic reasoning frameworks such as syllogism, which do not comprehensively examine the nuanced process of legal reasoning. Moreover, current research has largely focused on criminal cases, with insufficient modeling for civil cases. In this work, we present a novel framework to explicitly model legal reasoning in the analysis of Chinese tort-related civil cases. We first operationalize the legal reasoning process in tort analysis into the three-module LexChain framework, with each module consisting of multiple finer-grained sub-steps. Informed by the LexChain framework, we introduce the task of tort legal reasoning and construct an evaluation benchmark to systematically assess the critical steps within analytical reasoning chains for tort analysis. Leveraging this benchmark, we evaluate existing large language models for their legal reasoning ability in civil tort contexts. Our results indicate that current models still fall short in accurately handling crucial elements of tort legal reasoning. Furthermore, we introduce several baseline approaches that explicitly incorporate LexChain-style reasoning through prompting or post-training. The proposed baselines achieve significant improvements in tort-related legal reasoning and generalize well to related legal analysis tasks, demonstrating the value of explicitly modeling legal reasoning chains to enhance the reasoning capabilities of language models.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。