arXiv:2510.18333cs.CRcs.CL2025-10ACL被引 12

让大模型水印真正落地,关键在对齐各方利益。

Position: LLM Watermarking Should Align Stakeholders' Incentives for Practical Adoption

  • 以可信方嵌入指令的上下文水印,实现无损检测
  • 三类水印中仅上下文水印能自然对齐各方利益
  • 适合会议评审、教育场景等有信任基础的领域

尽管大语言模型(LLM)水印算法取得进展,实际部署仍有限。我们指出,这源于模型提供方、平台与终端用户间激励错配,表现为三大障碍:竞争风险、检测工具治理权以及责任归属问题。从这一视角重审三类水印:模型水印天然契合提供方利益,但在开源生态中面临新挑战;文本水印作为防滥用工具,对提供方收益有限,仅在数据去污或用户溯源等特定场景可行;而上下文水印(ICW)专为可信方设计,如会议组织者或教师,将隐藏水印指令嵌入文档,若不诚实的审稿人或学生提交至模型,输出将携带可检测水印以识别滥用。该机制对齐了三方利益:用户无质量损失,可信方获得检测工具,模型提供方只需执行指令保持中立。我们倡导探索更多此类激励对齐方法,并提炼出面向特定领域的水印设计原则与研究方向。结论是,水印的实际应用需在具体场景中对齐利益,并推动社区共同参与。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Despite progress in watermarking algorithms for large language models (LLMs), real-world deployment remains limited. We argue that this gap stems from misaligned incentives among LLM providers, platforms, and end users, which manifest as three key barriers: competitive risk, detection-tool governance, and attribution issues. We revisit three classes of watermarking through this lens. \emph{Model watermarking} naturally aligns with LLM provider interests, yet faces new challenges in open-source ecosystems. \emph{LLM text watermarking} offers modest provider benefit when framed solely as an anti-misuse tool, but can gain traction in narrowly scoped settings such as dataset de-contamination or user-controlled provenance. \emph{In-context watermarking} (ICW) is tailored for trusted parties, such as conference organizers or educators, who embed hidden watermarking instructions into documents. If a dishonest reviewer or student submits this text to an LLM, the output carries a detectable watermark indicating misuse. This setup aligns incentives: users experience no quality loss, trusted parties gain a detection tool, and LLM providers remain neutral by simply following watermark instructions. We advocate for a broader exploration of incentive-aligned methods, with ICW as an example, in domains where trusted parties need reliable tools to detect misuse. More broadly, we distill design principles for incentive-aligned, domain-specific watermarking and outline future research directions. Our position is that the practical adoption of LLM watermarking requires aligning stakeholder incentives in targeted application domains and fostering active community engagement.

大模型水印激励对齐可信应用

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。