用强化学习解释家庭消费在经济下行时的异常行为
Reinforcement Learning and Consumption-Savings Behavior
- 用神经网络近似Q-learning模拟家庭决策,突破理性预期假设
- 低资产失业者对刺激支出的边际消费倾向达0.50,高于高资产者(0.34)
- 曾多次失业者即使当前状况改善,消费仍长期偏低,体现创伤效应
本文表明,强化学习可解释经济下行期间家庭消费行为中的两个悖论现象。构建一个代理使用神经网络近似Q-learning进行收入不确定下的消费储蓄决策,突破标准理性预期假设。模型复现了近期文献中的两个关键发现:(1) 无借贷约束下,此前流动性资产较低的失业家庭对刺激转移的边际消费倾向(MPC)为0.50,显著高于高资产家庭的0.34,与Ganong等(2024)一致;(2) 曾有更多失业经历的家庭,在控制当前经济状况后,消费水平持续更低,体现“创伤”效应,如Malmendier和Shen(2024)所证。不同于基于收入风险信念更新或事前异质性的解释,强化学习通过随经验演化的价值函数近似误差,同时生成更高的MPC和更低的消费水平。模拟结果与实证估计高度吻合,表明适应性学习机制为理解过往经历如何塑造当前消费行为提供统一框架。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
This paper demonstrates how reinforcement learning can explain two puzzling empirical patterns in household consumption behavior during economic downturns. I develop a model where agents use Q-learning with neural network approximation to make consumption-savings decisions under income uncertainty, departing from standard rational expectations assumptions. The model replicates two key findings from recent literature: (1) unemployed households with previously low liquid assets exhibit substantially higher marginal propensities to consume (MPCs) out of stimulus transfers compared to high-asset households (0.50 vs 0.34), even when neither group faces borrowing constraints, consistent with Ganong et al. (2024); and (2) households with more past unemployment experiences maintain persistently lower consumption levels after controlling for current economic conditions, a "scarring" effect documented by Malmendier and Shen (2024). Unlike existing explanations based on belief updating about income risk or ex-ante heterogeneity, the reinforcement learning mechanism generates both higher MPCs and lower consumption levels simultaneously through value function approximation errors that evolve with experience. Simulation results closely match the empirical estimates, suggesting that adaptive learning through reinforcement learning provides a unifying framework for understanding how past experiences shape current consumption behavior beyond what current economic conditions would predict.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。