用扩散模型生成逼真颈椎X光片,专家难辨真假。
Expert Validation of Synthetic Cervical Spine Radiographs Generated with a Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Model
- 用DDPM模型基于4963张真实图像生成合成颈椎侧位片。
- 专家盲评显示合成图与真图在真实感上无显著差异。
- 适合需要大规模标注数据的神经外科影像研究者。
神经外科中的机器学习受限于高质量影像数据集的构建。合成数据提供了一种可扩展且保护隐私的解决方案。本研究评估了使用去噪扩散概率模型(DDPM)生成逼真侧位颈椎X光片的可行性,模型在4,963张来自《颈椎X光图谱》的数据上训练。通过训练/验证损失和弗雷歇初始距离监控模型性能,合成图像质量在由六名神经放射科医生和两名脊柱专科培训神经外科医生参与的盲法“临床图灵测试”中评估。专家审查了50组共200张图像(每组含一张真实图和三张合成图),识别真实图像并按4分制李克特量表评分真实感。专家正确识别真实图像的比例为29%(Fleiss' kappa=0.061)。真实图像平均真实感得分为3.323,三组合成图像分别为3.228、3.258和3.320(与真实图像比较p值分别为0.383、0.471、1.000)。近邻分析未发现记忆现象。研究还发布了包含20,063张合成图像的数据集。结果表明,DDPM生成的颈椎X光片在真实感和质量上与真实临床图像无统计学差异,为地标定位、分割和分类等机器学习应用提供了大规模神经影像数据的新途径。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Machine learning in neurosurgery is limited by challenges in assembling large, high-quality imaging datasets. Synthetic data offers a scalable, privacy-preserving solution. We evaluated the feasibility of generating realistic lateral cervical spine radiographs using a denoising diffusion probabilistic model (DDPM) trained on 4,963 images from the Cervical Spine X-ray Atlas. Model performance was monitored via training/validation loss and Frechet inception distance, and synthetic image quality was assessed in a blinded "clinical Turing test" with six neuroradiologists and two spine-fellowship trained neurosurgeons. Experts reviewed 50 quartets containing one real and three synthetic images, identifying the real image and rating realism on a 4-point Likert scale. Experts correctly identified the real image in 29% of trials (Fleiss' kappa=0.061). Mean realism scores were comparable between real (3.323) and synthetic images (3.228, 3.258, and 3.320; p=0.383, 0.471, 1.000). Nearest-neighbor analysis found no evidence of memorization. We also provide a dataset of 20,063 synthetic radiographs. These results demonstrate that DDPM-generated cervical spine X-rays are statistically indistinguishable in realism and quality from real clinical images, offering a novel approach to creating large-scale neuroimaging datasets for ML applications in landmarking, segmentation, and classification.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。