揭示催眠与大模型在自动响应、监控缺失和情境依赖上的深层相似性。
Automatic Minds: Cognitive Parallels Between Hypnotic States and Large Language Model Processing
- 通过自动模式补全机制生成行为,缺乏主动控制。
- 均出现幻觉或错构,因监控机制被削弱。
- 适合研究意识与智能关系的跨学科读者。
催眠状态下的认知过程与大语言模型(LLMs)的计算操作存在深层功能相似性。两者均通过有限或不可靠的执行监督,借助自动化的模式补全机制产生复杂且语境恰当的行为。本文从三个原则展开分析:自动性,即反应源于联想而非推理;监控抑制,导致催眠中的错构与大模型的幻觉;情境依赖增强,即时提示(如治疗师建议或用户输入)压倒稳定知识。这些机制揭示了观察者相对的意义空白:系统生成连贯但无根基的输出,需外部解释者赋予意义。催眠与大模型均体现功能性自主——具备复杂、目标导向、情境敏感的行为能力,却无主观自我意识。这一区分阐明了目的性行为可脱离自我反思意识而产生,仅由结构与情境动态驱动。最后,二者共同揭示‘程式化’现象:自动、目标导向的模式生成,不伴随反思意识。催眠为理解意图如何脱离自觉思考提供了实验模型,有助于洞察人工系统的潜在动机机制。认识到这些类比表明,未来可靠AI应采用混合架构,融合生成流畅性与执行监控机制,借鉴人类心智的复杂自调节结构。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
The cognitive processes of the hypnotized mind and the computational operations of large language models (LLMs) share deep functional parallels. Both systems generate sophisticated, contextually appropriate behavior through automatic pattern-completion mechanisms operating with limited or unreliable executive oversight. This review examines this convergence across three principles: automaticity, in which responses emerge from associative rather than deliberative processes; suppressed monitoring, leading to errors such as confabulation in hypnosis and hallucination in LLMs; and heightened contextual dependency, where immediate cues (for example, the suggestion of a therapist or the prompt of the user) override stable knowledge. These mechanisms reveal an observer-relative meaning gap: both systems produce coherent but ungrounded outputs that require an external interpreter to supply meaning. Hypnosis and LLMs also exemplify functional agency - the capacity for complex, goal-directed, context-sensitive behavior - without subjective agency, the conscious awareness of intention and ownership that defines human action. This distinction clarifies how purposive behavior can emerge without self-reflective consciousness, governed instead by structural and contextual dynamics. Finally, both domains illuminate the phenomenon of scheming: automatic, goal-directed pattern generation that unfolds without reflective awareness. Hypnosis provides an experimental model for understanding how intention can become dissociated from conscious deliberation, offering insights into the hidden motivational dynamics of artificial systems. Recognizing these parallels suggests that the future of reliable AI lies in hybrid architectures that integrate generative fluency with mechanisms of executive monitoring, an approach inspired by the complex, self-regulating architecture of the human mind.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。