AI主权不是非黑即白,需平衡自主与全球协作。
Sovereign AI: Rethinking Autonomy in the Age of Global Interdependence
- 提出主权AI连续体模型,四支柱均衡配置
- 印度数据算力强但模型自主弱,中东侧重阿拉伯语模型
- 主张有管控的开放,避免封闭式自保
人工智能正成为基础通用技术,带来全球互联时代的新主权困境。尽管各国寻求控制,但其底层依赖全球数据流、芯片供应链、开源生态和国际标准,难以被封闭。本文构建概念与形式框架,将主权AI视为连续而非二元状态,权衡自主与依存。基于经典理论与历史类比,提出两类政策启发:在四个主权支柱间使边际回报均等;在全局收益等于暴露风险时设定开放度。应用于印度,发现其在数据、算力和规范方面有主权基础,但模型自主性较弱。短期挑战在于通过数据与算力协同投资、全生命周期治理(ModelOps)及受保护采购实现整合。应用于中东(沙特与阿联酋),大规模投入阿拉伯语优先模型与主权云,显示高主权权重、低财政约束及数据与算力强互补性。最优策略为有防护的内部开放。跨场景启示是:AI主权需要的是受控的相互依存,而非孤立。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Artificial intelligence (AI) is emerging as a foundational general-purpose technology, raising new dilemmas of sovereignty in an interconnected world. While governments seek greater control over it, the very foundations of AI--global data pipelines, semiconductor supply chains, open-source ecosystems, and international standards--resist enclosure. This paper develops a conceptual and formal framework for understanding sovereign AI as a continuum rather than a binary condition, balancing autonomy with interdependence. Drawing on classical theories, historical analogies, and contemporary debates on networked autonomy, we present a planner's model that identifies two policy heuristics: equalizing marginal returns across the four sovereignty pillars and setting openness where global benefits equal exposure risks. We apply the model to India, highlighting sovereign footholds in data, compute, and norms but weaker model autonomy. The near-term challenge is integration via coupled Data x Compute investment, lifecycle governance (ModelOps), and safeguarded procurement. We then apply the model to the Middle East (Saudi Arabia and the UAE), where large public investment in Arabic-first models and sovereign cloud implies high sovereignty weights, lower effective fiscal constraints, and strong Data x Compute complementarities. An interior openness setting with guardrails emerges as optimal. Across contexts, the lesson is that sovereignty in AI needs managed interdependence, not isolation.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。