提出教师与生成式AI协同五层次框架,助力教育智能化转型
Towards Synergistic Teacher-AI Interactions with Generative Artificial Intelligence
- 构建从协作到协同的五级教师-AI互动模型
- 强调协同阶段实现能力互补与共同决策,超越单方主导
- 适合关注AI教育应用伦理与实践融合的研究者与教育工作者
生成式人工智能(GenAI)在教育中的应用日益广泛,给教师适应带来挑战。尽管GenAI在可及性、可扩展性和生产效率方面提供前所未有的机遇,但其对教学任务的自动化引发教师自主性下降、认知退化及职业边缘化的担忧。本文基于前期文献与最新系统综述,提出教师与AI协作的五个层级:交易型、情境型、操作型、实践型和协同型。该框架旨在刻画教师与GenAI互动的复杂动态,揭示其可能带来的替代、互补或增强效应。文中讨论了支持协同所需的GenAI技术特性及实证研究,并基于观察提出未来愿景:教师与AI通过协商、建设性质疑和共同推理,实现能力互促,达成独立无法实现的教育成果。同时探讨了影响协同的社会技术因素,以实现教育中人机协同的伦理与实践平衡。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly used in education, posing significant challenges for teachers adapting to these changes. GenAI offers unprecedented opportunities for accessibility, scalability and productivity in educational tasks. However, the automation of teaching tasks through GenAI raises concerns about reduced teacher agency, potential cognitive atrophy, and the broader deprofessionalisation of teaching. Drawing findings from prior literature on AI in Education, and refining through a recent systematic literature review, this chapter presents a conceptualisation of five levels of teacher-AI teaming: transactional, situational, operational, praxical and synergistic teaming. The framework aims to capture the nuanced dynamics of teacher-AI interactions, particularly with GenAI, that may lead to the replacement, complementarity, or augmentation of teachers' competences and professional practice. GenAI technological affordances required in supporting teaming, along with empirical studies, are discussed. Drawing on empirical observations, we outline a future vision that moves beyond individual teacher agency toward collaborative decision-making between teachers and AI, in which both agents engage in negotiation, constructive challenge, and co-reasoning that enhance each other's capabilities and enable outcomes neither could realise independently. Further discussion of socio-technical factors beyond teacher-AI teaming is also included to streamline the synergy of teachers and AI in education ethically and practically.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。