arXiv:2511.23241cs.CV2025-11被引 1

用合成数据训练工业检测模型,简单特征方法比生成式AI更高效准确。

Synthetic Industrial Object Detection: GenAI vs. Feature-Based Methods

  • 通过亮度和感知哈希筛选合成数据,实现低成本特征对齐。
  • 感知哈希法在工业与机器人数据集上分别达98%和67%的mAP50。
  • 生成式AI耗时长且性能不优于简单特征方法,适合资源充足场景。

降低数据生成与标注成本是机器学习在工业与机器人场景中低成本部署的关键挑战。尽管合成渲染有潜力,但弥合仿真到现实的差距通常需要专家干预。本文评估了多种领域随机化(DR)与领域自适应(DA)技术,包括基于特征的方法、生成式AI(GenAI)及传统渲染方法,用于生成无需人工标注的上下文合成数据。重点考察低层与高层特征对齐的效果与效率,以及基于提示引导的扩散模型控制型DA方法。在两个数据集上验证:一个专有的工业数据集(汽车与物流)和一个公开的机器人数据集。结果显示,若以足够多样性的渲染数据为种子,简单的特征方法(如亮度与感知哈希过滤)在准确率与资源效率上均优于复杂的GenAI方法。感知哈希表现最佳,工业与机器人数据集上的mAP50分别达到98%和67%。此外,GenAI方法在数据生成上存在显著时间开销,且未带来模拟到现实性能的明显提升。研究为高效弥合仿真-现实差距提供了可操作建议,使仅基于合成数据训练的模型也能获得高真实世界表现。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Reducing the burden of data generation and annotation remains a major challenge for the cost-effective deployment of machine learning in industrial and robotics settings. While synthetic rendering is a promising solution, bridging the sim-to-real gap often requires expert intervention. In this work, we benchmark a range of domain randomization (DR) and domain adaptation (DA) techniques, including feature-based methods, generative AI (GenAI), and classical rendering approaches, for creating contextualized synthetic data without manual annotation. Our evaluation focuses on the effectiveness and efficiency of low-level and high-level feature alignment, as well as a controlled diffusion-based DA method guided by prompts generated from real-world contexts. We validate our methods on two datasets: a proprietary industrial dataset (automotive and logistics) and a public robotics dataset. Results show that if render-based data with enough variability is available as seed, simpler feature-based methods, such as brightness-based and perceptual hashing filtering, outperform more complex GenAI-based approaches in both accuracy and resource efficiency. Perceptual hashing consistently achieves the highest performance, with mAP50 scores of 98% and 67% on the industrial and robotics datasets, respectively. Additionally, GenAI methods present significant time overhead for data generation at no apparent improvement of sim-to-real mAP values compared to simpler methods. Our findings offer actionable insights for efficiently bridging the sim-to-real gap, enabling high real-world performance from models trained exclusively on synthetic data.

合成数据工业检测特征对齐生成式AI

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。