用视觉语言模型检测文生图模型的27种常见错误,提升评估可靠性。
FineGRAIN: Evaluating Failure Modes of Text-to-Image Models with Vision Language Model Judges
- 用视觉语言模型判断文生图结果是否符合提示中的27种特定错误模式。
- 发现当前模型在属性准确性和物体表征上存在系统性偏差。
- 适合关注生成模型可解释性与评测方法的研究者使用。
文生图(T2I)模型虽能生成视觉吸引人的图像,却常无法准确捕捉用户提示中的特定属性,如物体数量和颜色。这类错误类型多样,亟需分层评估框架来比较不同生成模型对提示的遵循能力。同时,视觉语言模型(VLM)的评测基准尚未跟上其标注复杂场景的能力。本文提出一种联合评估文生图模型与视觉语言模型的方法:测试多个VLM(Molmo、InternVL3、Pixtral)能否识别由5个文生图模型(Flux、SD3-Medium、SD3-Large、SD3.5-Medium、SD3.5-Large)在挑战性提示下生成的图像中的27种具体失败模式。我们构建了一个包含提示、生成图像及由大语言模型(Llama3)标注的视觉语言模型注释数据集。通过分析精选提示下的失败模式,揭示了属性保真度与物体表征方面的系统性错误。研究指出现有评估指标难以捕捉这些细微缺陷,强调针对性基准对提升生成模型可靠性与可解释性的关键作用。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Text-to-image (T2I) models are capable of generating visually impressive images, yet they often fail to accurately capture specific attributes in user prompts, such as the correct number of objects with the specified colors. The diversity of such errors underscores the need for a hierarchical evaluation framework that can compare prompt adherence abilities of different image generation models. Simultaneously, benchmarks of vision language models (VLMs) have not kept pace with the complexity of scenes that VLMs are used to annotate. In this work, we propose a structured methodology for jointly evaluating T2I models and VLMs by testing whether VLMs can identify 27 specific failure modes in the images generated by T2I models conditioned on challenging prompts. Our second contribution is a dataset of prompts and images generated by 5 T2I models (Flux, SD3-Medium, SD3-Large, SD3.5-Medium, SD3.5-Large) and the corresponding annotations from VLMs (Molmo, InternVL3, Pixtral) annotated by an LLM (Llama3) to test whether VLMs correctly identify the failure mode in a generated image. By analyzing failure modes on a curated set of prompts, we reveal systematic errors in attribute fidelity and object representation. Our findings suggest that current metrics are insufficient to capture these nuanced errors, highlighting the importance of targeted benchmarks for advancing generative model reliability and interpretability.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。