教你怎么选AI模式:别乱用智能体,该用就用,不该用就省事省钱。
STRIDE: A Systematic Framework for Selecting AI Modalities -- Agentic AI, AI Assistants, or LLM Calls
- 按任务拆解+动态性判断+自我反思分析,自动评分决定用哪种AI模式
- 在30个真实任务中准确率92%,减少45%不必要的智能体使用,降本37%
- 适合运维、合规等企业场景,帮工程师避免过度设计智能体
从无状态大语言模型转向自主目标驱动的智能体,带来一个核心问题:何时真正需要智能体?尽管智能体支持多步推理、持久记忆和工具调度,但盲目部署会增加成本、复杂性和风险。本文提出STRIDE(系统化任务推理智能部署评估框架),提供三类模式的合理选择建议:(i) 直接调用LLM,(ii) 有引导的AI助手,(iii) 完全自主的智能体。STRIDE融合结构化任务分解、动态性归属分析与自我反思需求评估,生成‘智能体适用性得分’,确保仅在任务本身具有内在动态性或上下文演化时才启用全自主模式。在涵盖SRE、合规与企业自动化领域的30个真实任务上评估,STRIDE实现了92%的模态选择准确率,减少45%不必要的智能体部署,资源成本降低37%。经过六个月在SRE和合规领域的专家验证,领域专家一致认为其能有效区分需简单调用LLM、有引导助手或完全自主智能体的任务。该工作将智能体采纳重构为必要性驱动的设计决策,确保自主性仅在收益大于成本时才被采用。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
The rapid shift from stateless large language models (LLMs) to autonomous, goal-driven agents raises a central question: When is agentic AI truly necessary? While agents enable multi-step reasoning, persistent memory, and tool orchestration, deploying them indiscriminately leads to higher cost, complexity, and risk. We present STRIDE (Systematic Task Reasoning Intelligence Deployment Evaluator), a framework that provides principled recommendations for selecting between three modalities: (i) direct LLM calls, (ii) guided AI assistants, and (iii) fully autonomous agentic AI. STRIDE integrates structured task decomposition, dynamism attribution, and self-reflection requirement analysis to produce an Agentic Suitability Score, ensuring that full agentic autonomy is reserved for tasks with inherent dynamism or evolving context. Evaluated across 30 real-world tasks spanning SRE, compliance, and enterprise automation, STRIDE achieved 92% accuracy in modality selection, reduced unnecessary agent deployments by 45%, and cut resource costs by 37%. Expert validation over six months in SRE and compliance domains confirmed its practical utility, with domain specialists agreeing that STRIDE effectively distinguishes between tasks requiring simple LLM calls, guided assistants, or full agentic autonomy. This work reframes agent adoption as a necessity-driven design decision, ensuring autonomy is applied only when its benefits justify the costs.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。