2025年超智能毁灭人类的说法缺乏实证,当前AI仍为有限模型。
Humanity in the Age of AI: Reassessing 2025's Existential-Risk Narratives
- 基于2023-2025年实证,未观测到智能爆炸、自主战略意识等关键现象
- 现有生成模型仅具统计能力,无致命误对齐或自我改进特征
- 风险叙事实为掩盖监控资本主义与算力集中的意识形态工具
两篇2025年出版物《AI 2027》(Kokotajlo等)与《若有人建成,人人皆亡》(Yudkowsky & Soares)断言,超级智能将在未来十年内几乎必然摧毁或使人类过时。二者沿用Good(1965)与Bostrom(2014)的经典链条:智能爆炸 → 超级智能 → 致命误对齐。本文对2023–2025年实证记录进行检验,六十年后,持续的递归自我改进、自主战略意识或不可解致命误对齐均未被观测到。当前生成模型仍是狭窄、统计训练的人工产物:强大、不透明、有缺陷,但缺乏使灾难情景可信的属性。援引Whittaker(2025a,b,c)与Zuboff(2019, 2025),我们指出存在性风险论调主要充当意识形态干扰,掩盖了监视资本主义的持续巩固与计算权力的极端集中。该论调更受2025年AI投机泡沫推动,数万亿美元投资于快速贬值的“数字生菜”硬件(McWilliams, 2025),掩盖了收入滞后与无就业增长,而非预示超级智能。截至2025年11月,该论断仍仅为被投机泡沫放大的推测性假设,非已证实概率。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Two 2025 publications, "AI 2027" (Kokotajlo et al., 2025) and "If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies" (Yudkowsky & Soares, 2025), assert that superintelligent artificial intelligence will almost certainly destroy or render humanity obsolete within the next decade. Both rest on the classic chain formulated by Good (1965) and Bostrom (2014): intelligence explosion, superintelligence, lethal misalignment. This article subjects each link to the empirical record of 2023-2025. Sixty years after Good's speculation, none of the required phenomena (sustained recursive self-improvement, autonomous strategic awareness, or intractable lethal misalignment) have been observed. Current generative models remain narrow, statistically trained artefacts: powerful, opaque, and imperfect, but devoid of the properties that would make the catastrophic scenarios plausible. Following Whittaker (2025a, 2025b, 2025c) and Zuboff (2019, 2025), we argue that the existential-risk thesis functions primarily as an ideological distraction from the ongoing consolidation of surveillance capitalism and extreme concentration of computational power. The thesis is further inflated by the 2025 AI speculative bubble, where trillions in investments in rapidly depreciating "digital lettuce" hardware (McWilliams, 2025) mask lagging revenues and jobless growth rather than heralding superintelligence. The thesis remains, in November 2025, a speculative hypothesis amplified by a speculative financial bubble rather than a demonstrated probability.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。