用可控制的医院环境评估大模型在完整诊疗流程中的表现
CP-Env: Evaluating Large Language Models on Clinical Pathways in a Controllable Hospital Environment
- 构建模拟医院生态的智能体环境,支持从分诊到多学科会诊的全流程交互
- 多数模型在复杂路径中出现幻觉,丢失关键诊断信息,且过度推理反致效果下降
- 适合医疗AI研发者、临床决策系统开发者使用,推动真实场景下的能力评测
医疗照护涉及跨越多个阶段的复杂临床路径,远超孤立的医患互动,强调决策与阶段转换。现有基准多聚焦静态测试或孤立对话,难以有效评估大语言模型(LLMs)在动态临床场景中的表现。我们提出CP-Env——一个可控的代理型医院环境,用于评估LLMs在端到端临床路径中的表现。该环境模拟包含患者与医生智能体的医院生态系统,构建从分诊、专科会诊、诊断检测到多学科团队会议等多样化场景,支持分支结构与长时程任务执行,遵循真实医院的自适应医疗流程。我们设计三层次评估框架:临床有效性、流程胜任力与专业伦理。结果表明,多数模型难以应对路径复杂性,常出现幻觉并丢失关键诊断细节;有趣的是,过多推理步骤反而可能适得其反,而顶尖模型则表现出通过内化知识减少工具依赖的趋势。CP-Env为医疗AI智能体的发展提供全面端到端评估支持。相关基准与评估工具已开源,详见 https://github.com/SPIRAL-MED/CP_ENV。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Medical care follows complex clinical pathways that extend beyond isolated physician-patient encounters, emphasizing decision-making and transitions between different stages. Current benchmarks focusing on static exams or isolated dialogues inadequately evaluate large language models (LLMs) in dynamic clinical scenarios. We introduce CP-Env, a controllable agentic hospital environment designed to evaluate LLMs across end-to-end clinical pathways. CP-Env simulates a hospital ecosystem with patient and physician agents, constructing scenarios ranging from triage and specialist consultation to diagnostic testing and multidisciplinary team meetings for agent interaction. Following real hospital adaptive flow of healthcare, it enables branching, long-horizon task execution. We propose a three-tiered evaluation framework encompassing Clinical Efficacy, Process Competency, and Professional Ethics. Results reveal that most models struggle with pathway complexity, exhibiting hallucinations and losing critical diagnostic details. Interestingly, excessive reasoning steps can sometimes prove counterproductive, while top models tend to exhibit reduced tool dependency through internalized knowledge. CP-Env advances medical AI agents development through comprehensive end-to-end clinical evaluation. We provide the benchmark and evaluation tools for further research and development at https://github.com/SPIRAL-MED/CP_ENV.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。