用部分标签学习提升心电图诊断在模糊标注下的准确性
Investigating ECG Diagnosis with Ambiguous Labels using Partial Label Learning
- 将九种部分标签学习算法适配到多标签心电图诊断
- 在真实临床数据上,部分标签学习整体优于传统监督训练
- 揭示现有方法对不同模糊类型敏感,适合临床模糊数据研究
标签模糊是真实心电图诊断中固有的挑战,源于疾病重叠和诊断分歧。然而当前心电图模型多假设标签清晰无歧义,限制了模型在真实场景下的发展与评估。尽管部分标签学习(PLL)框架专为处理模糊标签设计,其在医疗时序数据、尤其是心电图领域的应用仍鲜有研究。本文首次系统研究了PLL方法在真实与受控模糊条件下的心电图诊断表现。首先,将九种PLL算法适配至多标签心电图诊断,在存在多位医生诊断分歧的真实临床数据上进行详细评估;其次,引入多种临床相关的合成模糊标签以在受控条件下深入分析。实验表明,不同PLL方法在各类模糊程度和类型下表现差异显著;且总体上,PLL优于标准监督训练。通过深入分析,识别出当前方法在临床场景中的关键局限,并提出未来构建鲁棒、临床对齐的模糊感知学习框架的方向。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Label ambiguity is an inherent and largely unaddressed challenge in real-world electrocardiogram (ECG) diagnosis, arising from overlapping conditions and diagnostic disagreements. However, current ECG models are trained assuming clean and non-ambiguous annotations, limiting both the development and meaningful evaluation of models under real-world conditions. Although Partial Label Learning (PLL) frameworks are designed to learn from ambiguous labels, their effectiveness in medical time-series domains, ECG in particular, remains largely underexplored. We present the first systematic study of PLL methods for ECG diagnosis under both real and controlled ambiguity. First, we adapt nine PLL algorithms to multi-label ECG diagnosis under label ambiguity, and perform detailed evaluations on real clinical settings with multi-annotator diagnostic disagreements. Next, to study PLL effects on ECG in more depth under controlled settings, we introduce a diverse set of clinically motivated synthetic label ambiguities. Our experiments demonstrate that PLL methods vary substantially in robustness across ambiguity types and levels. Moreover, we observe that PLL generally outperforms standard supervised training under label ambiguity, highlighting the value of such frameworks. Through extensive analysis, we identify key limitations of current PLL approaches for clinical settings and outline future directions for developing robust and clinically aligned ambiguity-aware learning frameworks for ECG diagnosis.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。