AI可能威胁文化权利与发展权,需重构全球治理框架
Cultural Rights and the Rights to Development in the Age of AI: Implications for Global Human Rights Governance
- 分析AI在文化创作与知识产权中的影响机制
- 揭示算法设计加剧数字与社会不平等的现实风险
- 为政策制定者提供跨领域人权治理的参考方向
文化权利与发展权是国际人权法的核心原则。然而,人工智能(AI)及其相关数字技术的快速发展对这两类权利的保护与实现构成严峻挑战。这主要源于AI系统对文化内容创造与呈现的影响,对个人及群体知识产权使用与分配的干预,以及对全球文化参与和表达的广泛作用。同时,AI的普及可能加剧已有的经济、社会与数字鸿沟,进一步强化边缘群体的不平等地位。这一动态冲击了文化权利与发展权之间的既有互动关系,并引发关于如何将文化与发展考量纳入新兴AI治理框架的深层问题。本文从概念层面剖析了AI在认知与规范层面对文化与发展假设的局限性,考察了其在个体与结构层面的双重影响。基于此,识别出现有AI治理框架在文化权利与发展权方面的缺失与张力。通过将文化权利与发展权置于AI与人权的整体图景中,本文推动了关于AI伦理、法律框架与国际人权法的学术讨论,并提出未来研究与政策发展的路径,依托现有全球AI治理对话。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Cultural rights and the right to development are essential norms within the wider framework of international human rights law. However, recent technological advances in artificial intelligence (AI) and adjacent digital frontier technologies pose significant challenges to the protection and realization of these rights. This owes to the increasing influence of AI systems on the creation and depiction of cultural content, affect the use and distribution of the intellectual property of individuals and communities, and influence cultural participation and expression worldwide. In addition, the growing influence of AI thus risks exacerbating preexisting economic, social and digital divides and reinforcing inequities for marginalized communities. This dynamic challenges the existing interplay between cultural rights and the right to development, and raises questions about the integration of cultural and developmental considerations into emerging AI governance frameworks. To address these challenges, the paper examines the impact of AI on both categories of rights. Conceptually, it analyzes the epistemic and normative limitations of AI with respect to cultural and developmental assumptions embedded in algorithmic design and deployment, but also individual and structural impacts of AI on both rights. On this basis, the paper identifies gaps and tensions in existing AI governance frameworks with respect to cultural rights and the right to development. By situating cultural rights and the right to development within the broader landscape of AI and human rights, this paper contributes to the academic discourse on AI ethics, legal frameworks, and international human rights law. Finally, it outlines avenues for future research and policy development based on existing conversations in global AI governance.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。