arXiv:2512.20714cs.AIcs.CY2025-12综述被引 7

生成式AI可精准支持计算机教育个性化,但需设计得当才能真正提升学习效果。

From Pilots to Practices: A Scoping Review of GenAI-Enabled Personalization in Computer Science Education

  • 通过解释优先、分步提示等设计提升学生自主思考
  • 结合学生代码和评分标准的智能辅导更有效
  • 适合教育研究者与课程设计者参考落地策略

生成式AI可在大规模计算机科学教育中实现个性化教学,但其对学习的真实影响仍存疑。本范围综述从259条记录中精选32项研究(2023–2025年),梳理高等教育场景下的个性化机制与成效信号。识别出五大应用领域:智能导师、个性化材料、形成性反馈、AI增强评估和代码评审。研究发现,采用解释先行引导、解题延迟、渐进提示阶梯及基于学生代码、测试和评分标准的具象化设计,显著优于无约束聊天界面。成功实践共享四类模式:基于学生作品的上下文感知辅导、需反思的多层级提示结构、与传统CS基础设施(自动评分器、评分标准)融合,以及人工介入的质量保障。提出探索先行采纳框架,强调试点、监测、保留学习过程的默认设置和证据驱动扩展。常见风险包括学术诚信、隐私、偏见与公平性、过度依赖,已配套操作缓解策略。证据表明,当嵌入可审计工作流且保留适度挑战时,生成式AI可作为精准支架的有效工具。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Generative AI enables personalized computer science education at scale, yet questions remain about whether such personalization supports or undermines learning. This scoping review synthesizes 32 studies (2023-2025) purposively sampled from 259 records to map personalization mechanisms and effectiveness signals in higher-education computer science contexts. We identify five application domains: intelligent tutoring, personalized materials, formative feedback, AI-augmented assessment, and code review, and analyze how design choices shape learning outcomes. Designs incorporating explanation-first guidance, solution withholding, graduated hint ladders, and artifact grounding (student code, tests, and rubrics) consistently show more positive learning processes than unconstrained chat interfaces. Successful implementations share four patterns: context-aware tutoring anchored in student artifacts, multi-level hint structures requiring reflection, composition with traditional CS infrastructure (autograders and rubrics), and human-in-the-loop quality assurance. We propose an exploration-first adoption framework emphasizing piloting, instrumentation, learning-preserving defaults, and evidence-based scaling. Recurrent risks include academic integrity, privacy, bias and equity, and over-reliance, and we pair these with operational mitigation. The evidence supports generative AI as a mechanism for precision scaffolding when embedded in audit-ready workflows that preserve productive struggle while scaling personalized support.

生成式AI教育技术个性化学习计算机教育

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。