arXiv:2512.21246cs.HCcs.AI2025-12被引 1

比较初中与高中生使用AI学习时的感知因素差异。

Learning Factors in AI-Augmented Education: A Comparative Study of Middle and High School Students

  • 通过课堂实测分析学生对体验、清晰度、舒适感和动机的感知关系。
  • 初中生各维度强相关,感知整体一致;高中生则弱相关,评价独立。
  • 揭示年龄影响学生与AI互动的感知结构,指导分龄AI教育设计。

AI工具在教育中的应用日益广泛,但现有研究多集中于高等教育和传统教学场景,对不同年龄阶段学生在AI辅助学习环境中关键学习因素(体验、清晰度、舒适感、动机)之间的关联性及其差异关注不足。本研究在真实课堂中开展编程学习活动,收集初中与高中生对四类学习因素的感知数据。采用多方法量化分析(相关性分析与文本挖掘),发现两组学生呈现显著不同的维度结构:初中生各维度间存在强正相关,表现为整体性评价模式,任一维度积极感受会泛化至其他维度;而高中生各维度间相关性微弱或接近零,表明其评价过程更为分化,各维度独立评估。结果表明,感知维度在AI增强学习中起主动中介作用,且发展水平调节其相互依赖性。该研究为针对学习者发展阶段定制的AI整合策略提供了基础。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

The increasing integration of AI tools in education has led prior research to explore their impact on learning processes. Nevertheless, most existing studies focus on higher education and conventional instructional contexts, leaving open questions about how key learning factors are related in AI-mediated learning environments and how these relationships may vary across different age groups. Addressing these gaps, our work investigates whether four critical learning factors, experience, clarity, comfort, and motivation, maintain coherent interrelationships in AI-augmented educational settings, and how the structure of these relationships differs between middle and high school students. The study was conducted in authentic classroom contexts where students interacted with AI tools as part of programming learning activities to collect data on the four learning factors and students' perceptions. Using a multimethod quantitative analysis, which combined correlation analysis and text mining, we revealed markedly different dimensional structures between the two age groups. Middle school students exhibit strong positive correlations across all dimensions, indicating holistic evaluation patterns whereby positive perceptions in one dimension generalise to others. In contrast, high school students show weak or near-zero correlations between key dimensions, suggesting a more differentiated evaluation process in which dimensions are assessed independently. These findings reveal that perception dimensions actively mediate AI-augmented learning and that the developmental stage moderates their interdependencies. This work establishes a foundation for the development of AI integration strategies that respond to learners' developmental levels and account for age-specific dimensional structures in student-AI interactions.

AI教育学习感知年龄差异教育心理学

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。