简单LSTM比复杂Transformer更准预测股价
StockBot 2.0: Vanilla LSTMs Outperform Transformer-based Forecasting for Stock Prices
- 用统一设置对比多种模型,发现基础LSTM表现最佳
- 在默认超参数下,LSTM预测准确率更高且交易决策更稳
- 适合数据少、调参难的金融时序预测场景
由于复杂的时序依赖、非线性动态和高波动性,金融市场的精准预测仍是长期挑战。基于我们此前的循环神经网络框架,本文提出增强版StockBot架构,在统一实验设置下系统评估现代注意力机制、卷积及循环时间序列模型。尽管注意力机制与Transformer类模型具备更强建模灵活性,但大量实证结果表明,在相同默认超参数下,精心构建的原始LSTM始终取得更优预测精度与更稳定的买入/卖出决策。该结果凸显了循环序列模型在金融时序预测中的鲁棒性与数据效率,尤其在缺乏充分超参数调优或数据量有限(按日离散化)时。此外,结果强调了架构先验偏置在数据受限的市场预测任务中的重要性。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Accurate forecasting of financial markets remains a long-standing challenge due to complex temporal and often latent dependencies, non-linear dynamics, and high volatility. Building on our earlier recurrent neural network framework, we present an enhanced StockBot architecture that systematically evaluates modern attention-based, convolutional, and recurrent time-series forecasting models within a unified experimental setting. While attention-based and transformer-inspired models offer increased modeling flexibility, extensive empirical evaluation reveals that a carefully constructed vanilla LSTM consistently achieves superior predictive accuracy and more stable buy/sell decision-making when trained under a common set of default hyperparameters. These results highlight the robustness and data efficiency of recurrent sequence models for financial time-series forecasting, particularly in the absence of extensive hyperparameter tuning or the availability of sufficient data when discretized to single-day intervals. Additionally, these results underscore the importance of architectural inductive bias in data-limited market prediction tasks.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。