arXiv:2601.05746cs.AI2026-01被引 3

让多个AI辩论更有效,避免集体犯错。

DynaDebate: Breaking Homogeneity in Multi-Agent Debate with Dynamic Path Generation

  • 用生成式代理动态创造多样化解题路径,打破思维同质化。
  • 聚焦逻辑步骤批判而非结果投票,提升推理严谨性。
  • 分歧时自动调用外部工具验证,解决僵局适合复杂任务场景。

近年来,基于大语言模型的多智能体系统(MAS)在协作决策与复杂问题求解中表现优异。研究者进一步探索了多智能体辩论(MAD)框架,通过智能体间的信息交换与辩论提升推理与协作能力。然而,现有方法常依赖无引导初始化,导致智能体采用相同推理路径并产生相同错误,削弱辩论有效性,最终结果往往退化为简单的多数表决。为此,我们提出动态多智能体辩论(DynaDebate),通过三个关键机制提升辩论效率:(1) 动态路径生成与分配,由专用路径生成代理生成多样且合理的解题路径,并自适应调节冗余度;(2) 过程中心型辩论,将焦点从表面结果投票转向对每一步逻辑的严格批判,确保过程正确性;(3) 触发式验证代理,当出现分歧时激活,利用外部工具客观解决僵局。实验表明,DynaDebate在多数基准测试中表现优于或媲美现有方法。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Recent years have witnessed the rapid development of Large Language Model-based Multi-Agent Systems (MAS), which excel at collaborative decision-making and complex problem-solving. Researchers have further investigated Multi-Agent Debate (MAD) frameworks, which enhance the reasoning and collaboration capabilities of MAS through information exchange and debate among multiple agents. However, existing approaches often rely on unguided initialization, causing agents to adopt identical reasoning paths that lead to the same errors. As a result, effective debate among agents is hindered, and the final outcome frequently degenerates into simple majority voting. To solve the above problem, we introduce Dynamic Multi-Agent Debate (DynaDebate), which enhances the effectiveness of multi-agent debate through three key mechanisms: (1) Dynamic Path Generation and Allocation, which employs a dedicated Path Generation Agent to generate diverse and logical solution paths with adaptive redundancy; (2) Process-Centric Debate, which shifts the focus from surface-level outcome voting to rigorous step-by-step logic critique to ensure process correctness; (3) A Trigger-Based Verification Agent, which is activated upon disagreement and uses external tools to objectively resolve deadlocks. Experiments show that DynaDebate achieves superior or highly competitive performance across the majority of benchmarks\footnote{The code is at https://github.com/nwpuLee2021/brianstorm.}.

多智能体辩论系统逻辑推理路径生成

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。