用AI促进集体智慧,让工程课堂从个人提问转向协作学习
From Individual Prompts to Collective Intelligence: Mainstreaming Generative AI in the Classroom
- 设计思维支架+分阶段AI辅助,推动学生协作推理
- 140名学生参与,组队讨论显著提升理解深度与创造力
- 适合教育者探索如何避免AI加剧学习不平等
工程课堂正越来越多尝试生成式AI(GenAI),但多数仍局限于个体提问与孤立帮助,可能加剧教育不公平,仅惠及已有优势的学生。本文倡导转向以集体智能(CI)为核心的教学模式,让GenAI成为促进同伴学习的催化剂。我们在两门本科生工程课中实施了生成式集体智能(GCI)活动,通过哈佛零项目开发的思维支架(如问题分类、剥橘法)使思考可见,并结合战略性AI咨询,帮助学生外化推理过程、比较观点并迭代优化想法。研究融合学习科学、集体智能、具身认知与技术哲学,结合学生问卷与观察数据。结果显示,学生认可人机协同的价值,在警惕过度依赖的同时,认为群体协作比单独使用AI更利于深入理解与创造性解决问题;且AI介入时机显著影响学习效果。本文提出可推广的实践路径,助力构建更具参与性、抗挫力与知识共担意识的教学生态。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Engineering classrooms are increasingly experimenting with generative AI (GenAI), but most uses remain confined to individual prompting and isolated assistance. This narrow framing risks reinforcing equity gaps and only rewarding the already privileged or motivated students. We argue instead for a shift toward collective intelligence (CI)-focused pedagogy, where GenAI acts as a catalyst for peer-to-peer learning. We implemented Generative CI (GCI) activities in two undergraduate engineering courses, engaging 140 students through thinking routines -- short, repeatable scaffolds developed by Harvard Project Zero to make thinking visible and support collaborative sense-making. Using routines such as Question Sorts and Peel the Fruit, combined with strategic AI consultation, we enabled students to externalize their reasoning, compare interpretations, and iteratively refine ideas. Our dual-pronged approach synthesizes literature from learning sciences, CI, embodied cognition, and philosophy of technology, while also empirically learning through student surveys and engagement observations. Results demonstrate that students value the combination of human collaboration with strategic AI support, recognizing risks of over-reliance while appreciating AI's role in expanding perspectives. Students identified that group work fosters deeper understanding and creative problem-solving than AI alone, with the timing of AI consultation significantly affecting learning outcomes. We offer practical implementation pathways for mainstreaming CI-focused pedagogy that cultivates deeper engagement, resilient problem-solving, and shared ownership of knowledge.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。