分析异常声音检测中代理任务的有效性,发现并非表现越好越有助于检测异常。
Quantitative Analysis of Proxy Tasks for Anomalous Sound Detection
- 系统评估五类代理任务在正常声音上的表现与异常检测能力的关系
- 分类任务因难度不足出现性能饱和,对比学习因数据多样性差效果不佳
- 只有声音分离任务与异常检测呈强正相关,提示任务设计需关注难度和目标对齐
异常声音检测(ASD)通常依赖自监督代理任务,从正常声音数据中学习特征表示,因异常样本稀缺。常见代理任务如自编码器基于正常数据训练后,异常将导致重建误差增大。尽管有假设认为代理任务性能提升会增强检测能力,但该关系缺乏系统研究。本研究通过五种配置——自编码器、分类、源分离、对比学习及预训练模型——定量分析代理任务指标与ASD性能的关系。采用线性探测(线性可分性)和马氏距离(分布紧凑性)评估特征表示质量。实验表明,代理任务性能优异并不必然提升异常检测效果:分类任务因任务难度不足而出现性能饱和;对比学习因数据多样性有限未能学习有效特征。值得注意的是,仅源分离任务表现出显著正相关,分离性能提升始终伴随检测性能提升。研究强调任务难度与目标对齐的关键作用,并提出三阶段对齐验证协议,以指导高效代理任务的设计。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Anomalous sound detection (ASD) typically involves self-supervised proxy tasks to learn feature representations from normal sound data, owing to the scarcity of anomalous samples. In ASD research, proxy tasks such as AutoEncoders operate under the explicit assumption that models trained on normal data will increase the reconstruction errors related to anomalies. A natural extension suggests that improved proxy task performance should improve ASD capability; however, this relationship has received little systematic attention. This study addresses this research gap by quantitatively analyzing the relationship between proxy task metrics and ASD performance across five configurations, namely, AutoEncoders, classification, source separation, contrastive learning, and pre-trained models. We evaluate the learned representations using linear probe (linear separability) and Mahalanobis distance (distributional compactness). Our experiments reveal that strong proxy performance does not necessarily improve anomalous sound detection performance. Specifically, classification tasks experience performance saturation owing to insufficient task difficulty, whereas contrastive learning fails to learn meaningful features owing to limited data diversity. Notably, source separation is the only task demonstrating a strong positive correlation, such that improved separation consistently improves anomaly detection. Based on these findings, we highlight the critical importance of task difficulty and objective alignment. Finally, we propose a three-stage alignment verification protocol to guide the design of highly effective proxy tasks for ASD systems.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。