研究非专家如何理解机器人基础模型的性能表现。
How Users Understand Robot Foundation Model Performance through Task Success Rates and Beyond
- 通过真实评估数据和失败案例,考察用户对任务成功率的理解。
- 非专家能正确使用任务成功率,且重视未被充分报告的失败案例。
- 用户既需历史真实数据,也想要机器人对新任务的预测能力。
机器人基础模型(RFMs)为开发通用家用机器人提供了新路径。由于RFM具备广泛能力,用户难免会要求其执行未训练或未评估的任务。此时,用户必须理解尝试新任务的风险,因失败成本较高。同时,了解模型能力的用户才能判断机器人能否胜任特定场景。本文研究非机器人领域的用户如何解读来自RFM评估的性能信息。这些评估通常以任务成功率为首要指标。尽管该指标对专家直观易懂,但需验证新手是否同样正确使用。为此,我们开展实验,向用户展示多个已发表研究项目的真实评估数据,包括任务成功率(TSR)、失败案例描述及视频。结果表明,非专家不仅以符合专家预期的方式使用TSR,还高度关注失败案例等较少报告的信息。此外,用户希望获得两方面支持:一是机器人在过往任务中的真实表现数据,二是机器人对新任务完成可能性的自我估计。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Robot Foundation Models (RFMs) represent a promising approach to developing general-purpose home robots. Given the broad capabilities of RFMs, users will inevitably ask an RFM-based robot to perform tasks that the RFM was not trained or evaluated on. In these cases, it is crucial that users understand the risks associated with attempting novel tasks due to the relatively high cost of failure. Furthermore, an informed user who understands an RFM's capabilities will know what situations and tasks the robot can handle. In this paper, we study how non-roboticists interpret performance information from RFM evaluations. These evaluations typically report task success rate (TSR) as the primary performance metric. While TSR is intuitive to experts, it is necessary to validate whether novices also use this information as intended. Toward this end, we conducted a study in which users saw real evaluation data, including TSR, failure case descriptions, and videos from multiple published RFM research projects. The results highlight that non-experts not only use TSR in a manner consistent with expert expectations but also highly value other information types, such as failure cases that are not often reported in RFM evaluations. Furthermore, we find that users want access to both real data from previous evaluations of the RFM and estimates from the robot about how well it will do on a novel task.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。