arXiv:2602.13713cs.CL2026-02中稿 · version of the pap…被引 1

用理论增强大模型,精准识别话语重述的修辞功能

On Theoretically-Driven LLM Agents for Multi-Dimensional Discourse Analysis

  • 构建多智能体框架,用理论知识提升重述功能识别能力
  • 理论增强模型在强重述与泛化场景中表现显著更优,宏平均F1提升近30%
  • 适合研究修辞分析、论辩计算与可解释AI的学者使用

识别话语中重述的策略性用途仍是计算论辩的核心挑战。尽管大语言模型能检测表面相似性,却难以捕捉重述的语用功能,如其在修辞论述中的作用。本文提出一种对比式多智能体框架,用于量化引入显式理论知识对该任务的增益。我们利用标注的政治辩论数据集建立新标准,涵盖四种重述功能:去强化(Deintensification)、强化(Intensification)、具体化(Specification)、泛化(Generalisation),以及其它(Other),统称为D-I-S-G-O。随后评估两个并行的基于LLM的智能体系统:一个通过检索增强生成(RAG)融入论辩理论,另一个为零样本基线。结果表明,理论增强型智能体全面优于基线,尤其在强化与泛化语境中优势显著,整体宏平均F1得分提升近30%。研究证实,理论奠基不仅有益,更是实现功能感知的论辩话语分析所必需。该对比式多智能体架构为可扩展、理论驱动的计算工具迈出关键一步。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Identifying the strategic uses of reformulation in discourse remains a key challenge for computational argumentation. While LLMs can detect surface-level similarity, they often fail to capture the pragmatic functions of rephrasing, such as its role within rhetorical discourse. This paper presents a comparative multi-agent framework designed to quantify the benefits of incorporating explicit theoretical knowledge for this task. We utilise an dataset of annotated political debates to establish a new standard encompassing four distinct rephrase functions: Deintensification, Intensification, Specification, Generalisation, and Other, which covers all remaining types (D-I-S-G-O). We then evaluate two parallel LLM-based agent systems: one enhanced by argumentation theory via Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), and an identical zero-shot baseline. The results reveal a clear performance gap: the RAG-enhanced agents substantially outperform the baseline across the board, with particularly strong advantages in detecting Intensification and Generalisation context, yielding an overall Macro F1-score improvement of nearly 30\%. Our findings provide evidence that theoretical grounding is not only beneficial but essential for advancing beyond mere paraphrase detection towards function-aware analysis of argumentative discourse. This comparative multi-agent architecture represents a step towards scalable, theoretically informed computational tools capable of identifying rhetorical strategies in contemporary discourse.

论辩分析大模型修辞识别RAG

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。