arXiv:2602.14674cs.AI2026-02中稿 · AAMAS 2026 - With …被引 3

将用户偏好转化为论证基分,让AI推理更透明可解释

From User Preferences to Base Score Extraction Functions in Gradual Argumentation (with Appendix)

  • 从用户对论证的偏好推导出基分值,构建量化论证框架
  • 引入非线性偏好近似,提升基分提取与真实偏好的匹配度
  • 适用于需透明决策的场景,如机器人决策、推荐系统

渐进式论证是符号AI中的一个领域,因其支持透明且可争辩的AI系统而受到关注,广泛应用于决策、推荐、辩论分析等场景。这些应用的结果通常依赖于论证的基分,而基分的选择常需用户专业知识且过程复杂。通过组织论证的用户偏好,可简化此任务。本文提出‘基分提取函数’,将用户对论证的偏好映射为基分值,应用于带偏好的双极论证框架(BAF),生成量化双极论证框架(QBAF),从而使用成熟的渐进论证计算工具。我们定义了基分提取函数的理想性质,探讨设计选择,并提供基分提取算法。该方法引入人类偏好中非线性的近似,以更准确拟合真实偏好。最后在机器人场景中进行理论与实验评估,给出实践中选择合适渐进语义的建议。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Gradual argumentation is a field of symbolic AI which is attracting attention for its ability to support transparent and contestable AI systems. It is considered a useful tool in domains such as decision-making, recommendation, debate analysis, and others. The outcomes in such domains are usually dependent on the arguments' base scores, which must be selected carefully. Often, this selection process requires user expertise and may not always be straightforward. On the other hand, organising the arguments by preference could simplify the task. In this work, we introduce \emph{Base Score Extraction Functions}, which provide a mapping from users' preferences over arguments to base scores. These functions can be applied to the arguments of a \emph{Bipolar Argumentation Framework} (BAF), supplemented with preferences, to obtain a \emph{Quantitative Bipolar Argumentation Framework} (QBAF), allowing the use of well-established computational tools in gradual argumentation. We outline the desirable properties of base score extraction functions, discuss some design choices, and provide an algorithm for base score extraction. Our method incorporates an approximation of non-linearities in human preferences to allow for better approximation of the real ones. Finally, we evaluate our approach both theoretically and experimentally in a robotics setting, and offer recommendations for selecting appropriate gradual semantics in practice.

符号AI论证框架偏好学习透明决策

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。