AI生成创意易趋同,新方法通过提示词提升多样性。
Examining and Addressing Barriers to Diversity in LLM-Generated Ideas
- 用思维链提示减少AI思维固化,用普通人角色引导知识分布
- 双策略结合使AI创意多样性超过人类,且在四次实验中验证
- 适合希望避免AI创新同质化的团队与设计者使用
独立人类生成的创意通常比独立大模型生成的更具多样性,引发对过度依赖大模型导致创意趋同、损害社会创新的担忧。基于认知心理学,我们理论与实证发现两大机制:个体层面,大模型如人类一样存在早期输出锁定后续思路的现象;集体层面,大模型将知识整合为统一分布,缺乏人类群体中各人占据不同知识空间的分化特征。通过四项研究证明:思维链(CoT)提示可缓解个体固定化(仅在大模型中有效),普通人物角色(非‘创意企业家’如乔布斯)作为语义空间采样锚点,能增强知识分区。两者结合使创意多样性超越人类。该研究为理解大模型创意多样性提供理论框架,并给出兼顾效率与多样性的跨人类-AI协作方案。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Ideas generated by independent samples of humans tend to be more diverse than ideas generated from independent LLM samples, raising concerns that widespread reliance on LLMs could homogenize ideation and undermine innovation at a societal level. Drawing on cognitive psychology, we identify (both theoretically and empirically) two mechanisms undermining LLM idea diversity. First, at the individual level, LLMs exhibit fixation just as humans do, where early outputs constrain subsequent ideation. Second, at the collective level, LLMs aggregate knowledge into a unified distribution rather than exhibiting the knowledge partitioning inherent to human populations, where each person occupies a distinct region of the knowledge space. Through four studies, we demonstrate that targeted prompting interventions can address each mechanism independently: Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting reduces fixation by encouraging structured reasoning (only in LLMs, not humans), while ordinary personas (versus "creative entrepreneurs" such as Steve Jobs) improve knowledge partitioning by serving as diverse sampling cues, anchoring generation in distinct regions of the semantic space. Combining both approaches produces the highest idea diversity, outperforming humans. These findings offer a theoretically grounded framework for understanding LLM idea diversity and practical strategies for human-AI collaborations that leverage AI's efficiency without compromising the diversity essential to a healthy innovation ecosystem.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。