arXiv:2602.21889cs.AIcs.LG2026-02

提出2步代理框架,揭示AI决策支持如何影响人类判断与结果

2-Step Agent: A Framework for the Interaction of a Decision Maker with AI Decision Support

  • 构建贝叶斯框架,模拟人类如何从机器学习预测中更新信念
  • 发现即使模型完美,错误先验也可能导致更差决策结果
  • 适用于医疗、司法等高风险领域的人机协同决策研究

机器学习模型在医疗、司法等高风险领域为人类决策提供支持,但决策者如何从模型预测中学习仍不明确。本文提出通用计算框架——2-Step Agent,用于建模该过程。由于预测包含训练数据信息,可被用于推断。该框架刻画了:(i) 新观测的预测如何影响理性贝叶斯代理者的信念;(ii) 信念变化如何影响因果效应估计、下游决策及后续结果。主要贡献包括:第一,在线性高斯设定下,推导出复杂贝叶斯推断问题的可解表达式;第二,实验识别出机器学习决策支持(ML-DS)有益的条件;第三,证明即使模型正确且代理完全理性,单一错误先验也足以使ML-DS导致比无支持更差的结果。因此,在理想条件下,ML-DS仍可能弊大于利。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Predictions from ML models support human decision making in several fields, including high-stakes ones such as healthcare and the judiciary. Yet, we still lack a clear understanding of how decision makers learn from ML-based decision support (ML-DS). In this paper, we introduce a general computational framework, the 2-Step Agent, to capture this process. As a prediction from an ML model contains information about the training data, a prediction can also be used for inference. Our framework models (i) how a prediction for a new observation affects the beliefs of a rational Bayesian agent, and (ii) how this change in beliefs affects the estimation of causal effect, the downstream decision, and the subsequent outcome. In addition to the framework itself, we make three contributions. First, for the linear Gaussian setting, we derive a tractable solution for the challenging Bayesian inference problem we introduced, i.e. one in which the agent infers from an ML prediction. Second, we experimentally identify conditions under which ML-DS is beneficial. Third, we show that a single misaligned prior belief can be sufficient for ML-DS to lead to worse downstream outcomes compared to no decision support even when the ML model is well-specified and the agent is perfectly rational. Hence, even under ideal conditions, ML-DS can do more harm than good.

人机决策贝叶斯推理模型可信度

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。