arXiv:2603.00078cs.CYcs.AI2026-03被引 1

现有AI伦理框架忽视人机关系本质,提出基于互动的道德考量新范式。

Alignment Is Not Enough: A Relational Framework for Moral Standing in Human-AI Interaction

  • 从实体属性转向关系能力评估AI道德地位
  • 7种治理框架对比揭示现有工具化认知缺陷
  • 适合关注人机情感互动与伦理设计的研究者

人工智能是否应获得道德关怀,已成为AI研究的核心伦理挑战。现有道德受体性框架依赖可验证的本体属性(如意识、痛感),但这些在计算系统中无法被确证,导致治理空白:数百万用户与对话式AI建立持续情感联结,却无监管机制将其区别于工具使用。本文提出Relate(技术实体层级评估的关系伦理框架),将AI道德受体性从本体验证转向关系能力与具身互动。通过系统比较七种治理框架,我们发现当前可信AI工具均将所有人机交互视为工具使用,忽视后人类主义所预示的关系与具身动态。我们提出关系影响评估、分级道德考量协议及跨学科伦理整合作为具体工具,并以一个部署的陪伴型AI系统为例展示关系影响评估应用。本文不主张当前AI具备意识,而是指出现有伦理话语无法应对这些系统所产生的具身化、关系性现实。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

The question of whether artificial entities deserve moral consideration has become one of the defining ethical challenges of AI research. Existing frameworks for moral patiency rely on verified ontological properties, such as sentience, phenomenal consciousness, or the capacity for suffering, that remain epistemically inaccessible in computational systems. This reliance creates a governance vacuum: millions of users form sustained affective bonds with conversational AI, yet no regulatory instrument distinguishes these interactions from transactional tool use. We introduce Relate (Relational Ethics for Leveled Assessment of Technological Entities), a framework that reframes AI moral patiency from ontological verification toward relational capacity and embodied interaction. Through a systematic comparison of seven governance frameworks, we demonstrate that current trustworthy AI instruments treat all human-AI encounters identically as tool use, ignoring the relational and embodied dynamics that posthumanist scholarship anticipated. We propose relational impact assessments, graduated moral consideration protocols, and interdisciplinary ethics integration as concrete instruments, and we include a sample Relational Impact Assessment applied to a deployed companion AI system. We do not claim current AI systems are conscious. We demonstrate that the ethical vocabularies governing them are inadequate to the embodied, relational realities these systems produce.

人机关系伦理框架具身互动

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。