arXiv:2603.08865cs.NIcs.LG2026-03

实测发现5G通道指标好不等于吞吐高,需直接预测端到端性能。

Why Channel-Centric Models are not Enough to Predict End-to-End Performance in Private 5G: A Measurement Campaign and Case Study

  • 用实测数据对比仿真与机器学习模型,发现通道级指标无法准确预测吞吐。
  • 仿真器高估吞吐率,因误判多入多出层数为4层,实际仅1-3层。
  • 基于测量数据的高斯过程模型误差降低三分之二,适合通信感知规划。

通信感知的机器人路径规划需要精准预测无线网络性能。现有方法依赖接收信号强度、信噪比等通道级指标,假设其能可靠转化为端到端吞吐量。本文在私有5G工业环境中开展实测,评估商用射线追踪仿真器与数据驱动的高斯过程回归模型对吞吐量的预测表现。实验使用移动机器人采集数据,设备为市售终端,测试环境为地下、无线电屏蔽设施,具备精细三维建模,代表预测精度的最优场景。射线追踪仿真器能较好还原室内传播空间结构,通道级指标预测较准确,但系统性高估吞吐量,即使在视距条件下也如此。主要误差来源是过度估计可持续的MIMO空间层数:仿真假设接近均匀的四层传输,而实测显示实际适应性在1至3层之间。此差异导致即便通道指标良好,吞吐预测仍被夸大。相比之下,采用有理二次核的高斯过程模型通过直接学习实测吞吐量,将预测误差降低约三分之二,且偏差趋近于零。结果表明,良好的通道条件并不保证高吞吐量;仅依赖通道中心预测的通信感知规划可能产生过于乐观的轨迹,违反可靠性要求。5G吞吐量准确预测需对链路层模型进行大量校准,或采用捕捉真实系统行为的数据驱动方法。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Communication-aware robot planning requires accurate predictions of wireless network performance. Current approaches rely on channel-level metrics such as received signal strength and signal-to-noise ratio, assuming these translate reliably into end-to-end throughput. We challenge this assumption through a measurement campaign in a private 5G industrial environment. We evaluate throughput predictions from a commercial ray-tracing simulator as well as data-driven Gaussian process regression models against measurements collected using a mobile robot. The study uses off-the-shelf user equipment in an underground, radio-shielded facility with detailed 3D modeling, representing a best-case scenario for prediction accuracy. The ray-tracing simulator captures the spatial structure of indoor propagation and predicts channel-level metrics with reasonable fidelity. However, it systematically over-predicts throughput, even in line-of-sight regions. The dominant error source is shown to be over-estimation of sustainable MIMO spatial layers: the simulator assumes near-uniform four-layer transmission while measurements reveal substantial adaptation between one and three layers. This mismatch inflates predicted throughput even when channel metrics appear accurate. In contrast, a Gaussian process model with a rational quadratic kernel achieves approximately two-thirds reduction in prediction error with near-zero bias by learning end-to-end throughput directly from measurements. These findings demonstrate that favorable channel conditions do not guarantee high throughput; communication-aware planners relying solely on channel-centric predictions risk overly optimistic trajectories that violate reliability requirements. Accurate throughput prediction for 5G systems requires either extensive calibration of link-layer models or data-driven approaches that capture real system behavior.

5G吞吐预测机器人实测

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。